LLG 2021 Annual Meeting Minutes
This is a summary of the 2021 Annual Meeting of the members of the Logical Language Group, as conducted in the LLG Members Meeting channel on Mattermost from October 26, 2021 to April 11, 2022. A transcript is available.
Announcement
The 2021 Annual Meeting was announced on October 9, 2021, to commence on October 25, 2021. The announcement asked all recipients to redistribute it as widely as possible. The agenda was published as a shared spreadsheet:
Before the meeting opened, la-robotin-daiter asked whether participants could speak in Lojban. The president explained that English has long been the official language of LLG meetings, and that Lojban contributions are welcome when accompanied by an English translation.
Call to order
The meeting was first called to order on October 26, 2021 by president Karen Stein (.karis.).
Quorum
On November 3, la-robotin-daiter asked how the meeting could proceed with only six members present, and why inactive members were not removed. The president cited Article 4 of the Bylaws: provided notice has been sent as required, there is no minimum quorum. A majority of all voting members is needed only when notice is deemed insufficient, or for votes on Bylaw amendments. The president added that the existing procedure for removing members who have not participated in either of the two previous meetings or contacted a Board member did not apply to anyone this year.
Notice of meeting
A call for objections to the sufficiency of notice closed on November 7 with none received, and the president declared on November 8 that the meeting would proceed.
On November 12–13, maik (a visitor) reported that the October 9 announcement had largely failed to reach members:
- The message sent to [email protected] reached only a few people; the main Lojban list is [email protected].
- [email protected] is not a valid address, and the former [email protected] list had been decommissioned.
- Only the lojban-beginners list received the announcement.
- Chat postings were not propagated to Discord by the bridges, and the meeting channel itself is not bridged.
maik recommended that future announcements be sent to the main Lojban list and that members be asked to subscribe to it. maik forwarded the announcement to [email protected] on November 13; veion joined the meeting the same day after receiving it there.
On November 23, the president ended the meeting due to concern that notice had not been sufficiently distributed, and on November 28, 2021 called the meeting to order again. A renewed call for objections to notice received none, and on December 1 the president declared that the meeting would proceed under consensus that notice was sufficient.
Agenda
The order of business followed the bylaws of the LLG:
1. roll call 2. proof of notice of meeting or waiver of notice 3. reading of Minutes of preceding meeting 4. reports of Officers 5. reports of committees 6. proposal and approval of new members 7. election of Directors, if necessary 8. unfinished business 9. new business
Roll call
At lojbab's point of order, the president asked voting members to include their legal name in their attendance statement. At mukti's suggestion, participants were also invited to state preferred pronouns; ilmen and karis supported a default of "they" where no preference is given.
Members present:
- Karen Stein (karis)
- Robert LeChevalier (lojbab)
- Riley Lynch (mukti), formerly Riley Martinez-Lynch
- Arkadii Balandin (gleki)
- Nora LeChevalier (noras)
- Sylvain Dejardin (ilmen)
- Veijo Vilva (veion)
- Pierre Abbat (phma)
- And Rosta (.and.) — did not formally announce presence, but participated in New Business
Members listed as not having announced presence:
- Miles Forster (solpahi)
Visitors:
- maik
- la-robotin-daiter
- greg_g
Reading of minutes
The secretary, Riley Lynch, drafted minutes of the 2020 Annual Meeting and submitted them for amendment and approval:
No amendments were proposed.
President's report
Karen Stein reported that since the 2020 meeting ended in March 2021, the LLG had been mostly quiet as a group, though individual members and officers continued their activities across various online venues. No Board decisions were made between meetings. Much of the president's own time during the year was taken up by family matters.
Officers' reports
Vice President
Robert LeChevalier reported nothing of substance. He noted that LLG postal mail continues to arrive at his house, including items addressed to a vice president from about twenty years ago.
Secretary/Treasurer
Riley Lynch reported:
- He had registered the lojbangirz.org domain, following last year's discussion of separating official and community content, and intended to propose transferring it to the LLG. With documentation provided by Robin Lee Powell, LLG content could then be moved from lojban.org to the new domain.
- The LLG bank balance as of December 11, 2021 was $23,933.81, up $1,808.16 for the year from book sales. The only expenditures were registration and filing fees.
- The LLG's books had been kept in his personal copy of QuickBooks 2013. The laptop running it failed, but the hard drive was recovered. He proposed that the LLG subscribe to QuickBooks Online, to ease the handover to a future treasurer, and to a secrets-sharing service such as 1Password for managing access to shared assets.
Committee reports
The president noted that the LFK and the LLRC are the most recently created committees, and that no other committee had reported in several years.
Sylvain Dejardin (.ilmen.) reported no LFK activity since the last meeting.
maik reported that the LLRC charter is technically in effect, but no members were ever selected and the committee is defunct. Its work has in part been taken up by the independent Logical Languages Lodge Discord server, whose members maik said bear no ill will toward the LLG.
The president also created a public "Lojban Resources" channel to compile a fuller listing of Lojban chats, learning sites and other resources.
Election of new members
The president called for prospective new members on December 21, 2021. There were no proposals for new members.
Removal of old members
No members met the criteria for removal for non-participation.
Election of the Board
The following members stood for election to the Board:
- Stein, Karen (karis)
- Balandin, Arkadii (gleki)
- Lynch, Riley (mukti)
- LeChevalier, Robert (lojbab)
Voting ran from January 17 to January 21, 2022. The slate was elected with 6 votes in favour, none opposed and no abstentions.
Arkadii Balandin subsequently resigned from the Board and from LLG membership on March 22, 2022.
Old and new business
Old business
There were no items of Old Business on the agenda.
New business
Models for making products official
gleki proposed discussing new, less bureaucratic ways of making new or updated products official, arguing that committees created for the purpose tend to become defunct. He reported starting a dictionary project and adding around 200 example sentences to his edition of the CLL. The president noted that the CLL review was the only product currently in progress, and that responsibilities of an inactive committee can readily be moved to the membership or the Board.
lojbab later noted that committees exist not mainly for decision-making, but to handle specialized work that need not fall to an officer, or ongoing decisions the Board wants the broader membership involved in.
With gleki's agreement, the item was tabled on February 5, 2022.
Cancelling membership of inactive members
gleki proposed allowing the president, or alternatively the members present, to cancel the membership of de facto inactive members when quorum cannot be reached.
- And Rosta suggested suspension rather than cancellation, meaning cancellation with the expectation of easy reinstatement.
- lojbab noted that quorum is not an issue when proper notice is given, and that any removal should be a Board decision rather than that of a single officer, to guard against a faction packing the membership.
- .karis., .ilmen. and mukti considered cancellation sufficient, since reinstatement is easy and removals are made without prejudice to rejoining.
Voting was opened on March 1, 2022, scheduled to close on March 4, and was extended when few votes were received. The final tally was 3 in favor, none opposed, 1 abstention.
mukti suggested, as an aside, that future meetings be held in a time-bounded format, since participation suffers when a meeting stretches over many months.
gleki's relationship to lojban.org
gleki requested an explanation of the president's decision in February 2020 barring him from editing lojban.org, and proposed that the decision be reversed. The president restated her reasons: the membership had directed that official material be clearly distinguished from unofficial material, and gleki, as the main contributor, was asked to bring the site into line and declined. gleki disputed this account and asked for specific diffs of the changes in question.
Discussion included:
- lojbab accepted the president's position, but suggested gleki be allowed to submit page edits to a moderated queue reviewed by the Secretary/Treasurer, with restrictions eventually lifted once a record of following the standards was established. The president agreed this could also serve new contributors.
- phma supported reinstating gleki, provided the official/unofficial distinction was respected.
- .ilmen. noted that most wiki pages are open to any registered user, and suggested placing official content in a dedicated, restricted section with visible labelling, edited according to the Board's direction and monitored via page history or the MediaWiki "EditNotify" extension.
On March 22, 2022, gleki resigned from the Board and from LLG membership, stating he would continue his Lojban activities unofficially. With phma's concurrence, the item was dropped without a vote.
Next meeting
Members were asked to add topics and written proposals to the agenda for the next meeting by the end of July 2022, and to watch for announcements in mid to late August 2022:
Adjournment
With no further business raised, the meeting was declared concluded by the president on April 11, 2022 at 02:45 UTC.
- Previous meeting: 2020 annual meeting
- Following meeting: 2022 annual meeting
