Talk:Tiki forum archive/Forum 5/9088

From Lojban

Source: 2013 Tiki forum 5, thread #9088. Original authors, UTC times, post IDs, and reply-parent IDs are preserved. This is an archive, not an active article discussion.

Abstractors {ni} and {jei} (and {ka})

Abstractors {ni} and {jei} (and {ka})

dbrock · 2009-12-06 12:48 UTC · Tiki post #9088

There was some discussion on IRC about how to use {jei}, and of course

the more we talked about it the more nebulous it seemed.

It started with some innocent usage.

   <codrus> mi pensi lo jei lo nunkancu be fu lo lanme cu se stidi
     tezu'e lo nu pu tcica
   <kribacr> .i lo'u lo du'u xu kau le'u .e nai lo'u lo jei le'u
     jai se stidi mi doi .codrus.
   <kribacr> lo jei is looking for a number from 0 to 1
   <xalbo> I'm still not sure about {jei}, but I find myself
     wanting to use it for {du'u xu kau}, because the other
     seems utterly worthless.
   <xalbo> I suspect that in intensional contexts they may
     collapse together

Soon, the topic shifted to include {ni}.

   <xalbo> I'm far more worried about what {ni} actually means
   <xalbo> Honestly, I still don't completely have {ni} conceptualized.
   <xalbo> ISTR there were about three different meanings.
   <xalbo> I think the three competing meanings were "the number
     of ... such that ...", "the extent to which <full bridi>", and the
     property version ("the extent to which <bridi with a ce'u place>"
   <daniel`> xalbo: how would the property version be used?
   <xalbo> .i va'i sa'e mi do zmadu lo ni ce'u certu
   <daniel`> I see

I made the following ha-ha-only-serious suggestion.

   <daniel`> I think we should get an official ruling to
     declare {jei} and {ni} experimental cmavo

Others didn't quite agree:

   <xalbo> I think calling them experimental isn't productive.
     Just figure out what they do mean, and how to get the
     other meanings.

Still, everybody agreed that that nobody really knows what {ni} and {jei} mean. We talked about this some more, considering various alternatives. Here are some excerpts:

   <codrus> well here's what xorxes said on the list: "My answer
     is: "jei" is a useless word better forgotten, but those
     who use it generally use it to mean "du'u xu kau"
   <donri> i don't think jei *is* du'uxukau, but as it is useless,
     maybe that more useful interpretation that many make
     would be useful
   <xalbo> I tend to use {ni} for the property version, but
     sometimes the non-property "the extent to which" (and
     the fact that I do both of those bugs me)
   <xalbo> I never use it for "the number of", that's {du'u xo kau}
   <xalbo> Thinking more about it, I should use {jei} for the
     non-property {ni}.  That would be in line with most
     things, and just plain work.
   <xalbo> Although it takes out the 0-1 aspect, and replaces it
     with some scale.
   <daniel`> xalbo: that sounds sensible
   <daniel`> I had never heard of the property version of {ni}, but
     I think I like it
   <daniel`> in that case, {jei} : {ni} :: {du'u} : {ka}
   <xalbo> We absolutely need some property version of {ni}.  It's
     zmadu3, mleca3, zenba/jdika2, and many others.
   <daniel`> well, why not just {ka}?
   <xalbo> I (possibly mistakenly) conceptualize {ka} as boolean.
   <daniel`> me too, but I think {ka} is backwards-compatible with
     boolean use
   <codrus> xorxes said this about {ni}: ""ni" is not fully
     understood but it means something like "ka se la'u li
     xo kau"
   <daniel`> and if {ni} is a property, its x2 seems useless
   <donri> the x2 of ni then is the te la'u
   <daniel`> sure, but how are you going to use it?
   <daniel`> what is "the property of being large measured in
     meters" as opposed to "the property of being large"?
   <daniel`> {.i mi zenba lo ni clani kei be tu'a lo mitre}
     = "I increase in the number of meters long"?
   <donri> isn't it rather ka se la'u ba'e ce'u
   <daniel`> donri: that seems weird
   <daniel`> to say "I become longer", you'd have to say something
     like {.i li ci'i zenba lo ni mi clani}
   <daniel`> "Infinity is increasingly my height"
   <donri> ma ni lo citmle cu pinji do doi djanatyn
   <daniel`> {ma ni} is a very weird question [if ni1 is a property]

The discussion eventually died down. Later,

   <daniel`> I think we should declare that ni1 and jei1 are not
     properties but numbers, and that {ka} is not
     necessarily boolean-valued and so can be used with
     {zenba} and so on
   <codrus> xalbo: what do you think about daniel's proposal?
   <xalbo> I might accept the proposal.
   <daniel`> in that case, {ni} and {jei} are to first
     approximation equivalent
   <daniel`> and their difference is sort of like the difference
     between {zu'o} and {pu'u}


So, the point of this message is to ask about everybody's opinion on the following proposal:

* {lo jei broda kei be ko'a} is broda's truth value according to ko'a.
* {lo ni broda kei be ko'a} is broda's value on the scale ko'a.
* Neither {jei} nor {ni} have any {ce'u} place.

Examples:

 1. {.i lo du'u broda cu jetnu}
 "broda is true."
 2.1 {.i lo jei broda cu du li pa}
 "broda is completely true."
 2.2. {.i li pa jei broda}
 "broda is completely true."
 2.3. {.i li pi mu jei broda}
 "broda is half true, half false."
 3. {.i li pa re no la'e me'o .ibu ky.bu ni mi mencre}
 "120 on the IQ scale is my intelligence."
 4.1 {.i mi kucli lo du'u xu kau broda}
 "I wonder whether broda is true."
 4.2 {.i mi kucli lo du'u xo kau da broda}
 "I wonder how many broda."
 5.1 *{.i mi kucli lo jei broda} --- nonsense
 5.2 *{.i mi kucli lo ni broda} --- nonsense
 6.1 {.i mi kucli tu'a lo jei broda}
 "I wonder about brodas trueness."
 6.2 {.i mi kucli tu'a lo ni ko'a mencre}
 "I wonder about ko'a's IQ."
 (probably, "I wonder how smart ko'a is.")

Whether or not examples 6.1 and 6.2 are correct is dependent on whether {tu'a} and/or {lo} can introduce intensional contexts, which as I understand under xorlo they are supposed to. Note that this is a separate discussion.

 7.1. {.i mi kucli lo du'u ma kau broda}
 "I wonder how true broda is."
 7.2. {.i mi kucli lo du'u ma kau ni ko'a mencre}
 "I wonder how smart ko'a is."
 8.1 {.i ma ni do tatpi}
 "How tired are you on a scale?"
 "How tired are you?"
 8.2 {.i ma jei do tatpi}
 "How true is it that you are tired?"
 "How tired are you?"

Note that examples 8.1 and 8.2 are extremely similar, which is simply because {ni} and {jei} are very similar when the x2 is left out.

 9.1 {.i ma jei la .djisys. jmive kei lo xriso}
 "In Christianity, how true is it that Jesus is alive?"
 9.2 {.i ma ni la .djisys. jmive kei tu'a lo si'o remna}
 "How alive is Jesus as a human being?"
 9.3 {.i ma ni la .djisys. jmive kei tu'a lo si'o cevni}
 "How alive is Jesus as a god?"
 10.1 {.i mi zenba lo ka ce'u mencre}
 "I get smarter."
 10.2 *{.i mi zenba lo ni mencre} --- nonsense
 *"I increase in the property of the IQ of someone."
 10.3 {.i mi do zmadu lo ka mencre}
 "I'm smarter than you."
 11 *?{.i lo ni mi mencre cu zenba} --- nonsense?
 "My IQ increases."

Whether or not example 11 is correct depends on whether a number can increase. I'm not sure how this relates to intensionality and so on, so I explicitly leave example 11 open to debate.

But before we launch into that rabbit hole of a debate, let's please talk about all the other examples, because it's more important to come to some sort of consensus about the basics.

(Also note that example 11 can be easily turned into the unproblematic {.i mi zenba lo ka mencre}, and more generally the potentially problematic {.i lo ni ko'a broda cu zenba} can be turned into the unproblematic {.i ko'a zenba lo ka ce'u broda}. So an easy answer to {.i lo ni broda cu zenba} is just "please don't do that, as it needlessly confuses people and starts flamewars".)

Well, I guess that's enough to get started.

-- Daniel Brockman [email protected]


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

Abstractors {ni} and {jei} (and {ka})

Jorge Llambías <[email protected]> · 2009-12-06 12:51 UTC · Tiki post #9101 · reply to Tiki post #9088

On Thu, Nov 5, 2009 at 3:15 PM, Daniel Brockman <[email protected]> wrote:

[...] > Well, I guess that's enough to get started.

Great summary of the issue!

If you really want some official answers I suggest:

(1) you join the BPFK (obviously you are qualified) (2) you write the definitions for "ni" and "jei" (and perhaps for the rest of the NUs too, if you want).

That section is currently assigned to Robin, but he might be happy to give it to you if you ask nicely.

I have described the BPFK in the past as being dormant, but I don't think that's a fair description anymore. I think comatose is more appropriate at this point. We are in desperate need of new blood.

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

Abstractors {ni} and {jei} (and {ka})

lukebergen · 2009-12-06 12:51 UTC · Tiki post #9103 · reply to Tiki post #9088

that'd be awesome. I've heard that the main reason we're not trying to

promote lojban yet is that it's not "complete". But for completion the bpfk needs to finish definitions. But for bpfk to finish definitions they need to not be "comatose". But there are a set number of spots on it and no-one wants to relinquish their seat. How would dbrock get on (which I'm all for, he's hella jbo-knowledgeable whenever I've talked to him) without someone leaving.

2009/11/6 Jorge Llambías <[email protected]>

> On Thu, Nov 5, 2009 at 3:15 PM, Daniel Brockman <[email protected]> > wrote: > [...] > > Well, I guess that's enough to get started. > > Great summary of the issue! > > If you really want some official answers I suggest: > > (1) you join the BPFK (obviously you are qualified) > (2) you write the definitions for "ni" and "jei" (and perhaps for the > rest of the NUs too, if you want). > > That section is currently assigned to Robin, but he might be happy to > give it to you if you ask nicely. > > I have described the BPFK in the past as being dormant, but I don't > think that's a fair description anymore. I think comatose is more > appropriate at this point. We are in desperate need of new blood. > > mu'o mi'e xorxes > > > To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] > with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if > you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help. >

>

Abstractors {ni} and {jei} (and {ka})

Jorge Llambías <[email protected]> · 2009-12-06 12:51 UTC · Tiki post #9104 · reply to Tiki post #9088

On Fri, Nov 6, 2009 at 11:11 AM, Luke Bergen <[email protected]> wrote:

> But for bpfk to finish definitions they need > to not be "comatose". But there are a set number of spots on it and no-one > wants to relinquish their seat.

There is no such restriction. Anyone able and willing can join. There's no need for anyone to relinquish their seat.

> How would dbrock get on (which I'm all for, > he's hella jbo-knowledgeable whenever I've talked to him) without someone leaving.

He just needs to ask Robin, he is probably the one who knows what the exact formal procedure for joining is (if any). I suppose all it takes is approval by all or most the members, (or rather no explicit objections, as waiting for explicit approval could take for ever).

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

Abstractors {ni} and {jei} (and {ka})

arj · 2009-12-06 12:51 UTC · Tiki post #9105 · reply to Tiki post #9088

On Fri, Nov 06, 2009 at 09:11:34AM -0500, Luke Bergen wrote:

> that'd be awesome. I've heard that the main reason we're not trying to > promote lojban yet is that it's not "complete". But for completion the bpfk > needs to finish definitions. But for bpfk to finish definitions they need > to not be "comatose". But there are a set number of spots on it and no-one > wants to relinquish their seat.

This turns out not to be the case. There is an (informal) barrier to entry based on knowledge, but no fixed number of seats.

-- Arnt Richard Johansen http://arj.nvg.org/ Vacuum cleaners suck. Kings rule. Ice is cool.


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

Abstractors {ni} and {jei} (and {ka})

lukebergen · 2009-12-06 12:57 UTC · Tiki post #9107 · reply to Tiki post #9088

hmmm, maybe I'm thinking of the LLG.

Go DBRock! Finish those definitions so we can finally start marketing. I want more people in the community and for my friends to stop poking fun of my "made up language that nobodies ever heard of".

On Fri, Nov 6, 2009 at 9:27 AM, Arnt Richard Johansen <[email protected]> wrote:

> On Fri, Nov 06, 2009 at 09:11:34AM -0500, Luke Bergen wrote: > > that'd be awesome. I've heard that the main reason we're not trying to > > promote lojban yet is that it's not "complete". But for completion the > bpfk > > needs to finish definitions. But for bpfk to finish definitions they > need > > to not be "comatose". But there are a set number of spots on it and > no-one > > wants to relinquish their seat. > > This turns out not to be the case. There is an (informal) barrier to entry > based on knowledge, but no fixed number of seats. > > -- > Arnt Richard Johansen http://arj.nvg.org/ > Vacuum cleaners suck. Kings rule. Ice is cool. > > > To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] > with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if > you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help. >

>

Abstractors {ni} and {jei} (and {ka})

lagejyspa · 2009-12-06 12:57 UTC · Tiki post #9111 · reply to Tiki post #9088

On Thu, Nov 5, 2009 at 1:15 PM, Daniel Brockman <[email protected]> wrote:

> 7.1. {.i mi kucli lo du'u ma kau broda} > "I wonder how true broda is." > > 7.2. {.i mi kucli lo du'u ma kau ni ko'a mencre} > "I wonder how smart ko'a is." >

 Either I'm not getting something about your proposal, or you made  a

typo in 7.1. Shouldn't that be "i mi kucli lo du'u ma kau jei broda"?

As it stands, you are just curious about what thing(s) is/are broda
           --gejyspa


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

Abstractors {ni} and {jei} (and {ka})

dbrock · 2009-12-06 12:57 UTC · Tiki post #9112 · reply to Tiki post #9088

On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 8:28 PM, Michael Turniansky

<[email protected]> wrote: > On Thu, Nov 5, 2009 at 1:15 PM, Daniel Brockman <[email protected]> wrote: > >> 7.1. {.i mi kucli lo du'u ma kau broda} >> "I wonder how true broda is." >> >> 7.2. {.i mi kucli lo du'u ma kau ni ko'a mencre} >> "I wonder how smart ko'a is." >> > Either I'm not getting something about your proposal, or you made a > typo in 7.1. Shouldn't that be "i mi kucli lo du'u ma kau jei broda"? > As it stands, you are just curious about what thing(s) is/are broda

Right, that was a typo. Good catch.

-- Daniel Brockman [email protected]


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.