Talk:Tiki forum archive/Forum 5/9046

From Lojban

Source: 2013 Tiki forum 5, thread #9046. Original authors, UTC times, post IDs, and reply-parent IDs are preserved. This is an archive, not an active article discussion.

djuno lo jei

djuno lo jei

Thomas Jack <[email protected]> · 2009-12-05 12:57 UTC · Tiki post #9046

coi rodo

Example 7.3 in chapter 11 of the CLL is:

{mi djuno le jei la frank. cu bebna} "I know the truth-value of Frank being a fool."

It is noted that this means that "I know whether or not Frank is a fool."

Similarly we have example 7.6: {mi kucli le jei la frank. cu bebna} "I am curious about how true it is that Frank is a fool."

These examples seem strange to me. In section 6 of chapter 11, it is said that "the 'jei' abstraction refers to a number between 0 and 1 inclusive (as distinct from 'ni' abstractions, which are often on open-ended scales)."

(aside: Could we similarly say: {mi djuno le ni le pixra cu blanu} "I know the amount of blueness in the picture"?)

{lo jei la frank. cu bebna} is a truth-value, a number between 0 and 1 inclusive. Let's say Frank is really, truly, absolutely a fool. Wouldn't it be correct, then, that {lo jei la frank. cu bebna cu du li pa}? If so, is it then true that {mi djuno li pa}? Suppose also that Jane is really, trully, absolutely brilliant, so that {lo jei la djein cu mencre cu du li pa}. Then, is it true that {mi djuno lo jei la jein cu mencre}? I might not even know Jane! Whether or not we can actually get the {du li pa}s here, the truth-values of these sentences are certainly the same, so this last absurdity should be true, right? (A similar problem happens for {ni} abstractions used in this way, if they can be used in this way at all.)

I think I would want to translate "I know whether Frank is a fool" as {mi djuno lo du'u makau jei la frank cu bebna} (similarly for {ni}).

In general, given a sumti in a top-level bridi (certainly not abstracted, and perhaps there are other ways to get out of the "top-level", I dunno), and given that we have an identity statement about that sumti, can we substitute salva veritate in the original bridi? I feel like we should be able to. For example if {da broda} is true, and {da du de} is true, then {de broda} should also be true.

ki'e mi'e tomoj


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

djuno lo jei

Jorge Llambías <[email protected]> · 2009-12-05 12:57 UTC · Tiki post #9047 · reply to Tiki post #9046

On Tue, Oct 27, 2009 at 2:57 AM, Thomas Jack <[email protected]> wrote:

> > I think I would want to translate "I know whether Frank is a fool" as > {mi djuno lo du'u makau jei la frank cu bebna}

Yes, that corresponds to the direct question:

 ma jei la frank cu bebna
 What is the truth value of Frank being a fool?

but normally one would just ask:

 xu la frank bebna
 Is Frank a fool?

So a more straightforward way for the indirect question is:

 mi djuno lo du'u xu kau la frank cu bebna
 I know whether frank is a fool.

> In general, given a sumti in a top-level bridi (certainly not > abstracted, and perhaps there are other ways to get out of the > "top-level", I dunno), and given that we have an identity statement > about that sumti, can we substitute salva veritate in the original > bridi?

I would say yes.

> I feel like we should be able to. For example if {da broda} is > true, and {da du de} is true, then {de broda} should also be true.

How about putting it this way:

if {ko'a broda} is true, and {ko'a du ko'e} is true, then {ko'e broda} should also be true.

The problem with using "da" and "de" is that they are variables bound by quantifiers, and so your way of putting it could mean different things depending on what scope you have in mind for the quantifiers. Probably you are thinking of "ro da ro de zo'u" with scope over your whole English statement, which is a weird mix. If we are just considering the Lojban, we have:

su'o da zo'u da broda Something is a broda.

su'o da su'o de zo'u da du de Something is equal to something.

su'o de zo'u de broda Something is a broda.

If the first one is true, so is the third one, since they say exactly the same thing, just using different variables, and the second one is trivially true but irrelevant.

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.