Talk:Tiki forum archive/Forum 5/8961
Source: 2013 Tiki forum 5, thread #8961. Original authors, UTC times, post IDs, and reply-parent IDs are preserved. This is an archive, not an active article discussion.
selbri fa place and gadri question
selbri fa place and gadri question
lukebergen · 2009-12-05 11:37 UTC · Tiki post #8961
se/fa) always be to the left of the selbri? What was the design decision that leads {nelci mi do} to mean "someone (unspecified) likes me having something to do with you" instead of the seemingly obvious "like, I do you" -> "I like
you".
My second question came about when I was trying to think of how one might word my first question in lojban. I quickly realized that I needed a gadri that gets at the defining form of a word. So I wanted to say {ma lo krinu lo nu selbri cu se smuni ...} where the "" is some gadri which means "that x which defines what is a(n) x". So maybe another way to think about it would be, how would you say "lions are animals". Am I saying "the typical"? Not really, because all lions by definition are animals. It's not quite {ro da} either because I'm not talking about "all lions" but about "that quintessential lion (theoretical) which defines how lion-y a real world thing is".
- pafcribeselbri fa place and gadri question
lukebergen · 2009-12-05 11:35 UTC · Tiki post #8962 · reply to Tiki post #8961
se/fa) always be to the left of the selbri? What was the design decision that leads {nelci mi do} to mean "someone (unspecified) likes me having something to do with you" instead of the seemingly obvious "like, I do you" -> "I like you".
My second question came about when I was trying to think of how one might word my first question in lojban. I quickly realized that I needed a gadri that gets at the defining form of a word. So I wanted to say {ma lo krinu lo nu selbri cu se smuni ...} where the "" is some gadri which means "that x which defines what is a(n) x". So maybe another way to think about it would be, how would you say "lions are animals". Am I saying "the typical"? Not really, because all lions by definition are animals. It's not quite {ro da} either because I'm not talking about "all lions" but about "that quintessential lion (theoretical) which defines how lion-y a real world thing is".
- pafcribeselbri fa place and gadri question
Jorge Llambías <[email protected]> · 2009-12-05 11:37 UTC · Tiki post #8963 · reply to Tiki post #8961
> I have two questions. The first is: why MUST the x1 place (un-marked with > se/fa) always be to the left of the selbri? What was the design decision > that leads {nelci mi do} to mean "someone (unspecified) likes me having > something to do with you" instead of the seemingly obvious "like, I do you" > -> "I like you".
I wasn't there, but the received lore is that this was because when you transform a selbri into a sumti, you want the slot following the selbri to be the x2 slot: "lo nelci be do", "likers of you", because the x1 slot is the one picked by "lo".
OTOH, when transforming a selbri into a tag, it is the x1 slot that follows the selbri "fi'o nelci do", "with you as liker", so that explanation is not completely satisfying.
> My second question came about when I was trying to think of how one might > word my first question in lojban. I quickly realized that I needed a gadri > that gets at the defining form of a word. So I wanted to say {ma lo krinu > lo nu __ selbri cu se smuni ...}
(ma krinu lo nu ...)
> where the "__" is some gadri which means > "that x which defines what is a(n) x". So maybe another way to think about > it would be, how would you say "lions are animals".
.i lo cinfo cu danlu
.i ma krinu lo nu lo na'e se tcita sumti be fi li pa cu .ei lidne lo se sumti
> Am I saying "the > typical"? Not really, because all lions by definition are animals. It's > not quite {ro da} either because I'm not talking about "all lions" but about > "that quintessential lion (theoretical) which defines how lion-y a real > world thing is".
"Lions" is the basic meaning of "lo cinfo". It can also be used to refer to a particular lion or particular lions if they are especially salient in some context (i.e. restricted to something like "lions in this context") but without any context "lo cinfo" would just be lions in general.
mu'o mi'e xorxes
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
selbri fa place and gadri question
Jorge Llambías <[email protected]> · 2009-12-05 11:52 UTC · Tiki post #8965 · reply to Tiki post #8961
> I knew {lo} was flexible but I didn't know it was that flexible.
All "lo" does is convert a selbri into a sumti, selecting the x1 slot of the selbri so that the referent(s) of the resulting sumti will be things that fit that x1 slot. Any further specification, determination, restriction, qualification, quantification, partition, distribution, etc. of the referents, when and if needed, is better done by means other than a choice of gadri. Unfortunately, the existence of other cmavo in selma'o LE with additional information created the notion that "lo" also had to convey some additional information instead of remaining a neutral syntactic conversion, like for instance "fi'o". Nobody worries about what meaning "fi'o" has other han converting a selbri into a tag, but with "lo" it seems that conversion of a selbri into a sumti was not enough.
mu'o mi'e xorxes
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
selbri fa place and gadri question
lukebergen · 2009-12-05 11:52 UTC · Tiki post #8966 · reply to Tiki post #8961
kept trying to make it say extra stuff but when I think of it as a converter like a {fi'o} or {me} I get it.
Also
>yeah, I through that bridi together last second
- threw*
2009/10/6 Jorge Llambías <[email protected]>
> On Tue, Oct 6, 2009 at 11:34 AM, Luke Bergen <[email protected]> > wrote: > > I knew {lo} was flexible but I didn't know it was that flexible. > > All "lo" does is convert a selbri into a sumti, selecting the x1 slot > of the selbri so that the referent(s) of the resulting sumti will be > things that fit that x1 slot. Any further specification, > determination, restriction, qualification, quantification, partition, > distribution, etc. of the referents, when and if needed, is better > done by means other than a choice of gadri. Unfortunately, the > existence of other cmavo in selma'o LE with additional information > created the notion that "lo" also had to convey some additional > information instead of remaining a neutral syntactic conversion, like > for instance "fi'o". Nobody worries about what meaning "fi'o" has > other han converting a selbri into a tag, but with "lo" it seems that > conversion of a selbri into a sumti was not enough. > > mu'o mi'e xorxes > > > To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] > with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if > you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help. >
>selbri fa place and gadri question
lukebergen · 2009-12-05 11:53 UTC · Tiki post #8964 · reply to Tiki post #8961
thanks for the corrections. I knew {lo} was flexible but I didn't know it was *that* flexible.
2009/10/6 Jorge Llambías <[email protected]>
> On Tue, Oct 6, 2009 at 10:04 AM, Luke Bergen <[email protected]> > wrote: > > I have two questions. The first is: why MUST the x1 place (un-marked > with > > se/fa) always be to the left of the selbri? What was the design decision > > that leads {nelci mi do} to mean "someone (unspecified) likes me having > > something to do with you" instead of the seemingly obvious "like, I do > you" > > -> "I like you". > > I wasn't there, but the received lore is that this was because when > you transform a selbri into a sumti, you want the slot following the > selbri to be the x2 slot: "lo nelci be do", "likers of you", because > the x1 slot is the one picked by "lo". > > OTOH, when transforming a selbri into a tag, it is the x1 slot that > follows the selbri "fi'o nelci do", "with you as liker", so that > explanation is not completely satisfying. > > > My second question came about when I was trying to think of how one might > > word my first question in lojban. I quickly realized that I needed a > gadri > > that gets at the defining form of a word. So I wanted to say {ma lo > krinu > > lo nu __ selbri cu se smuni ...} > > (ma krinu lo nu ...) > > > where the "__" is some gadri which means > > "that x which defines what is a(n) x". So maybe another way to think > about > > it would be, how would you say "lions are animals". > > .i lo cinfo cu danlu > > .i ma krinu lo nu lo na'e se tcita sumti be fi li pa cu .ei lidne lo se > sumti > > > Am I saying "the > > typical"? Not really, because all lions by definition are animals. It's > > not quite {ro da} either because I'm not talking about "all lions" but > about > > "that quintessential lion (theoretical) which defines how lion-y a real > > world thing is". > > "Lions" is the basic meaning of "lo cinfo". It can also be used to > refer to a particular lion or particular lions if they are especially > salient in some context (i.e. restricted to something like "lions in > this context") but without any context "lo cinfo" would just be lions > in general. > > mu'o mi'e xorxes > > > To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] > with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if > you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help. >
>