Talk:Tiki forum archive/Forum 5/8611

From Lojban

Source: 2013 Tiki forum 5, thread #8611. Original authors, UTC times, post IDs, and reply-parent IDs are preserved. This is an archive, not an active article discussion.

potentially stupid question

potentially stupid question

lukebergen · 2009-12-03 12:00 UTC · Tiki post #8611

I was picturing the following scenario playing out between a lojbanic parent

and his/her child:

rirni: lo re titla cu banzu verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo rirni .i do binxo lo xlali verba verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo rirni .i o'onai .i lo nu do tavla cu ckape do verba: .i <pause> go'i fi lonu do tolxendo rirni .i o'onaicai .i .au mi darxi do

now I would think that a child learning a language as they grow would tend to see the generalities of a language and apply those generalities to unknown words and concepts. So wouldn't the child expect that the following response (un-doubtedly screamed while running for cover):

verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo

would continue to be clever and grammatically correct since "fi"

  • seems*like it usually means "under conditions"?

Could the constantly shifting places for concepts like "under conditions" cause natural learners of lojban to get confused?

mu'o mi'e pafcribe

potentially stupid question

Oleksii Melnyk <[email protected]> · 2009-12-03 11:59 UTC · Tiki post #8614 · reply to Tiki post #8611

ju'o go'i .i le verba cu di'i facki le cfipu morna le rarbau .i su'o

pagbu be la lojban cu cfipu le ciroi tadni la cll .i seni'ibo go'i le verba

2009/8/11, Luke Bergen <[email protected]>: > I was picturing the following scenario playing out between a lojbanic parent > and his/her child: > > rirni: lo re titla cu banzu > verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo > rirni .i do binxo lo xlali verba > verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo > rirni .i o'onai .i lo nu do tavla cu ckape do > verba: .i <pause> go'i fi lonu do tolxendo > rirni .i o'onaicai .i .au mi darxi do > > now I would think that a child learning a language as they grow would tend > to see the generalities of a language and apply those generalities to > unknown words and concepts. So wouldn't the child expect that the following > response (un-doubtedly screamed while running for cover): > > verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo > > would continue to be clever and grammatically correct since "fi" > *seems*like it usually means "under conditions"? > > Could the constantly shifting places for concepts like "under conditions" > cause natural learners of lojban to get confused? > > mu'o mi'e pafcribe >


-- mu'o mi'e lex


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

potentially stupid question

brablonau · 2009-12-03 11:59 UTC · Tiki post #8615 · reply to Tiki post #8611

Luke Bergen <[email protected]> writes:

> now I would think that a child learning a language as they grow would tend > to see the generalities of a language and apply those generalities to > unknown words and concepts. So wouldn't the child expect that the following > response (un-doubtedly screamed while running for cover): > > verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo > > would continue to be clever and grammatically correct since "fi" > *seems*like it usually means "under conditions"? > > Could the constantly shifting places for concepts like "under conditions" > cause natural learners of lojban to get confused?

Luke, I don't know what your native language is... I'm assuming it's English.

Children learning English have to contend with all sorts of confusing features of language... the irregularity of verbs like "to be" (am/are/is/etc.), homonyms like where/wear/we're and their/there, etc. Yet, somehow, kids (with, perhaps, a little schooling) manage to sort them all out. Lojban has no homonyms or irregulars like nat langs do. However, there is a whole mess of cmavo, rafsi, and (as you point out) structural elements to be learned.

Which language, over all, is easier to learn? I don't know. But if I had to bet, I'd put my money on Lojban.


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

potentially stupid question

lagejyspa · 2009-12-03 12:00 UTC · Tiki post #8616 · reply to Tiki post #8611

On Mon, Aug 10, 2009 at 10:45 PM, Luke Bergen <[email protected]> wrote:

> I was picturing the following scenario playing out between a lojbanic > parent and his/her child: > > rirni: lo re titla cu banzu > verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo > rirni .i do binxo lo xlali verba > verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo > rirni .i o'onai .i lo nu do tavla cu ckape do > verba: .i <pause> go'i fi lonu do tolxendo > rirni .i o'onaicai .i .au mi darxi do > > now I would think that a child learning a language as they grow would tend > to see the generalities of a language and apply those generalities to > unknown words and concepts. So wouldn't the child expect that the following > response (un-doubtedly screamed while running for cover): > > verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo > > would continue to be clever and grammatically correct since "fi" *seems*like it usually means "under conditions"? > > Could the constantly shifting places for concepts like "under conditions" > cause natural learners of lojban to get confused? >

 I dunno about all that, but I think the kid would more likely say

".imu'ibo do kusru" after each one, which would always work, rather than using the go'i construction, and is more accurate IMO, than "under conditions"

--gejyspa

potentially stupid question

lukebergen · 2009-12-03 12:04 UTC · Tiki post #8618 · reply to Tiki post #8611

yeah, I was just trying to think of an example where many different gismu

have the same position for the same concept and came up with "under conditions".

- Luke Bergen


On Wed, Aug 12, 2009 at 9:07 AM, Michael Turniansky <[email protected]>wrote:

> > > On Mon, Aug 10, 2009 at 10:45 PM, Luke Bergen <[email protected]>wrote: > >> I was picturing the following scenario playing out between a lojbanic >> parent and his/her child: >> >> rirni: lo re titla cu banzu >> verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo >> rirni .i do binxo lo xlali verba >> verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo >> rirni .i o'onai .i lo nu do tavla cu ckape do >> verba: .i <pause> go'i fi lonu do tolxendo >> rirni .i o'onaicai .i .au mi darxi do >> >> now I would think that a child learning a language as they grow would tend >> to see the generalities of a language and apply those generalities to >> unknown words and concepts. So wouldn't the child expect that the following >> response (un-doubtedly screamed while running for cover): >> >> verba: .i go'i fi lonu do tolxendo >> >> would continue to be clever and grammatically correct since "fi" *seems*like it usually means "under conditions"? >> >> Could the constantly shifting places for concepts like "under conditions" >> cause natural learners of lojban to get confused? >> > > I dunno about all that, but I think the kid would more likely say > ".imu'ibo do kusru" after each one, which would always work, rather than > using the go'i construction, and is more accurate IMO, than "under > conditions" > > --gejyspa > >

>