Talk:Tiki forum archive/Forum 5/8292
Source: 2013 Tiki forum 5, thread #8292. Original authors, UTC times, post IDs, and reply-parent IDs are preserved. This is an archive, not an active article discussion.
sel ter vel xel
sel ter vel xel
lukebergen · 2009-11-23 11:26 UTC · Tiki post #8292
wanting to cause another one of these is the main reason behind not changing "tel" for stela (lock) to something else is out of the question. But that was a while ago. Is it still completely out of the question to change just one little rafsi so we can have 100% consistency instead of 99.9% consistency?
I just picture teaching my kids lojban and them saying "but dad, you said that there are no exceptions toe the rules in lojban, why is the rafsi of 'te' 'ter' when all the others are just themselves plus 'l'?".
I know it's a cosmetic thing but it does kind of stick in my head like a thorn ya' know? "sel, ter, vel, xel". Blech.
- Luke Bergensel ter vel xel
adamgarrigus · 2009-11-23 11:26 UTC · Tiki post #8293 · reply to Tiki post #8292
> I know I've read something about a "great rafsi relocation" and that not > wanting to cause another one of these is the main reason behind not changing > "tel" for stela (lock) to something else is out of the question. But that > was a while ago. Is it still completely out of the question to change just > one little rafsi so we can have 100% consistency instead of 99.9% > consistency? > > I just picture teaching my kids lojban and them saying "but dad, you said > that there are no exceptions toe the rules in lojban, why is the rafsi of > 'te' 'ter' when all the others are just themselves plus 'l'?".
Are there any rules about rafsi besides their forms & the fact that every
gismu has at least one? Certainly there is no rule saying that the rafsi for
the SE-cmavo have to rhyme. Moreover, {ter-} is so commonly used that the
anomaly doesn't seem to cause much difficulty. And I would argue that
mistakenly using {tel-} in its place is unlikely to confound, due to the
semantic gap between {te} and {stela}. Lastly, a weighty argument against
drastically changing word meanings is retention of the intelligibility of
existing texts.
I agree that it's annoying, though.
mu'o mi'e komfo,amonansel ter vel xel
adamgarrigus · 2009-11-23 11:26 UTC · Tiki post #8294 · reply to Tiki post #8292
> On Sat, May 30, 2009 at 2:57 PM, Luke Bergen <[email protected]>wrote: > >> I know I've read something about a "great rafsi relocation" and that not >> wanting to cause another one of these is the main reason behind not changing >> "tel" for stela (lock) to something else is out of the question. But that >> was a while ago. Is it still completely out of the question to change just >> one little rafsi so we can have 100% consistency instead of 99.9% >> consistency? >> >> I just picture teaching my kids lojban and them saying "but dad, you said >> that there are no exceptions toe the rules in lojban, why is the rafsi of >> 'te' 'ter' when all the others are just themselves plus 'l'?". > > > Are there any rules about rafsi besides their forms & the fact that every > gismu has at least one? >
Well, I guess there are at least three gismu without rafsi -- {brodi},
{brodo}, {brodu} -- so scrap that rule. mu'o mi'e komfnsel ter vel xel
stevo · 2009-11-23 11:26 UTC · Tiki post #8295 · reply to Tiki post #8292
[email protected] writes:
> Well, I guess there are at least three gismu without rafsi -- {brodi},
> {brodo}, {brodu} -- so scrap that rule. mu'o mi'e komfn
>
Don't those three gismu each have a four-letter rafsi {brody-} and a five-letter rafsi that matches the gismu itself?
mu'o mi'e stevonsel ter vel xel
Adam Raizen <[email protected]> · 2009-11-23 11:26 UTC · Tiki post #8296 · reply to Tiki post #8292
> I know I've read something about a "great rafsi relocation" and that not > wanting to cause another one of these is the main reason behind not changing > "tel" for stela (lock) to something else is out of the question. But that > was a while ago. Is it still completely out of the question to change just > one little rafsi so we can have 100% consistency instead of 99.9% > consistency? >
The entire rafsi/lujvo system itself suffers from systemic inconsistency.
> I just picture teaching my kids lojban and them saying "but dad, you said
> that there are no exceptions toe the rules in lojban, why is the rafsi of
> 'te' 'ter' when all the others are just themselves plus 'l'?".
>
I can't imagine that your kids are going to be miffed about the rafsi for 'te' as opposed to the fact that the rafsi list itself increases the memory load of lojban by about 150% for no apparent benefit whatsoever.
-- Adam Raizen <[email protected]>
Got sente?sel ter vel xel
stevo · 2009-11-23 11:26 UTC · Tiki post #8297 · reply to Tiki post #8292
[email protected] writes:
> I can't imagine that your kids are going to be miffed about the rafsi for
> 'te' as opposed to the fact that the rafsi list itself increases the
> memory load of lojban by about 150% for no apparent benefit whatsoever.
>
You don't see a benefit in being able to combine five-letter gismu and get a word that's often only six letters? I think it's a great idea. I just wish that it had been done better. The rafsi are definitely a pain to learn.
mu'o mi'e stevonsel ter vel xel
Adam Raizen <[email protected]> · 2009-11-23 11:26 UTC · Tiki post #8298 · reply to Tiki post #8292
> In a message dated 5/31/2009 06:56:22 Eastern Daylight Time, > [email protected] writes: > > > I can't imagine that your kids are going to be miffed about the rafsi for > 'te' as opposed to the fact that the rafsi list itself increases the memory > load of lojban by about 150% for no apparent benefit whatsoever. > > > > You don't see a benefit in being able to combine five-letter gismu and get > a word that's often only six letters? I think it's a great idea. I just > wish that it had been done better. The rafsi are definitely a pain to > learn. >
Okay, so there's some benefit, but it's not nearly enough to begin to justify the huge memory load it requires. Why couldn't the rafsi themselves be the gismu?
-- Adam Raizen <[email protected]>
Got sente?sel ter vel xel
lukebergen · 2009-11-23 11:26 UTC · Tiki post #8299 · reply to Tiki post #8292
instance "ta'e" is the rafsi for tanxe "box". But it also means "habitually". This is why rafsi are not true lojbo valsi in and of themselves. I'm not sure it's possible, given the number of gismu, to have consistency in how all the rafsi are are formed. But I do wish that the cmavo would have some internal consistency, especially within individual selma'o in how the rafsi are formed.
Oh well, probably just a pipe dream.
- Luke Bergen
On Sun, May 31, 2009 at 3:58 PM, Adam Raizen <[email protected]> wrote:
> On Sun, May 31, 2009 at 21:52, <[email protected]> wrote: > >> In a message dated 5/31/2009 06:56:22 Eastern Daylight Time, >> [email protected] writes: >> >> >> I can't imagine that your kids are going to be miffed about the rafsi for >> 'te' as opposed to the fact that the rafsi list itself increases the memory >> load of lojban by about 150% for no apparent benefit whatsoever. >> >> >> >> You don't see a benefit in being able to combine five-letter gismu and get >> a word that's often only six letters? I think it's a great idea. I just >> wish that it had been done better. The rafsi are definitely a pain to >> learn. >> > > Okay, so there's some benefit, but it's not nearly enough to begin to > justify the huge memory load it requires. Why couldn't the rafsi themselves > be the gismu? > > -- > Adam Raizen <[email protected]> > Got sente? >
>sel ter vel xel
Adam Raizen <[email protected]> · 2009-11-23 11:26 UTC · Tiki post #8300 · reply to Tiki post #8292
> because sometimes rafsi by themselves are other words entirely. For > instance "ta'e" is the rafsi for tanxe "box". But it also means > "habitually". This is why rafsi are not true lojbo valsi in and of > themselves.
Of course it doesn't work with the current Lojban phonological system (given
the design goals), but there are a lot of very smart people here and I'm
sure that coming up with a system that fulfilled the same design goals as
Lojban but didn't require learners to memorize 0-3 extra combining forms for
every root word would not prove to be overly ambitious.
-- Adam Raizen <[email protected]>
Got sente?sel ter vel xel
stevo · 2009-11-23 11:26 UTC · Tiki post #8301 · reply to Tiki post #8292
[email protected] writes:
> I'm sure that coming up with a system that fulfilled the same design
> goals as Lojban but didn't require learners to memorize 0-3 extra combining
> forms for every root word would not prove to be overly ambitious.
>
One possibility would be to create the rafsi first, perhaps using all the CVC and CCV forms, neither of which can be a cmavo, then adding more or less arbitrary -CV to each one to make a gismu. Thus the first three letters of each gismu would provide a unique rafsi.
mu'o mi'e stevonsel ter vel xel
lukebergen · 2009-11-23 11:26 UTC · Tiki post #8302 · reply to Tiki post #8292
leave...... [17]*[5]*[17] = 1445 forms for CVC and (due to initial consonant pairs restriction) 48*5 = 240 for CCV form. Added together we have 1685.... that would be just about enough to cover the gismu that we have now with a little left over to spare.
I doubt that it would happen in lojban, but an interesting thought experiment morpheme
- Luke Bergen
On Mon, Jun 1, 2009 at 3:31 AM, <[email protected]> wrote:
> In a message dated 5/31/2009 23:57:24 Eastern Daylight Time, > [email protected] writes: > > > I'm > > sure that coming up with a system that fulfilled the same design goals as > Lojban but didn't require learners to memorize 0-3 extra combining forms for > every root word would not prove to be overly ambitious. > > > One possibility would be to create the rafsi first, perhaps using all the > CVC and CCV forms, neither of which can be a cmavo, then adding more or less > arbitrary -CV to each one to make a gismu. Thus the first three letters of > each gismu would provide a unique rafsi. > > mu'o mi'e stevon
>sel ter vel xel
John E Clifford <[email protected]> · 2009-11-23 11:26 UTC · Tiki post #8303 · reply to Tiki post #8292
________________________________
From: Luke Bergen <[email protected]>
To: [email protected]
Sent: Monday, June 1, 2009 8:28:14 AM
Subject: [lojban] Re: sel ter vel xel
That would be quite an undertaking. with only CVC and CCV forms that would leave...... [17]*[5]*[17] = 1445 forms for CVC and (due to initial consonant pairs restriction) 48*5 = 240 for CCV form. Added together we have 1685.... that would be just about enough to cover the gismu that we have now with a little left over to spare.
I doubt that it would happen in lojban, but an interesting thought experiment morpheme
- Luke Bergen
On Mon, Jun 1, 2009 at 3:31 AM, <[email protected]> wrote:
In a message dated 5/31/2009 23:57:24 Eastern Daylight Time, [email protected] writes:
I'msure that coming up with a system that fulfilled the same design goals as Lojban but didn't require learners to memorize 0-3 extra combining forms for every root word would not prove to be overly ambitious.
One possibility would be to create the rafsi first, perhaps using all the CVC and CCV forms, neither of which can be a cmavo, then adding more or less arbitrary -CV to each one to make a gismu. Thus the first three letters of each gismu would provide a unique rafsi.
mu'o mi'e stevon
sel ter vel xel
lagejyspa · 2009-11-23 11:27 UTC · Tiki post #8314 · reply to Tiki post #8292
> OK, I'll put this in the file for LoCCan3. It will pretty much kill the > 'easy to learn' 'feature' of the present system, but -- absent a test -- no > one seems to have believed that anyhow. I think this is the first > suggestion about phonolgy -- and immediately suggests the need to revise the > lujvo rules; any suggestions? >
I'm sure I haven't a clue what "LoCCan3" is, and I have REALLY no
desire to throw away all the aging brain cells I've already invested in learning lojban, but one of the phonological problems I've always had learning lojban is the of all the theoretical vastness of the gismu space, there is severe "clumping" in some areas, and other areas are completely unused. For example, there is ganra/grana/garna/gerna, xrani/xanri, cernba/cinba, tsina/tsani/tinsa, tinsa/rinsa/risna, racli/ralci, etc. etc. but not a single gismu with a pattern of *f*j*
- p*v* *v*v* *x*v* *z*x* or *z*z*, nor any gismu using any of more than
470 theoretically possible consonantal triples (in ANY order) such as {d,f,z} {d,s,z} {d,p,t}, {l,l,m}, {s,t,v} I know that this is driven by the gismu derivation paradigm, but I think any "reimagining" of lojban should give reasonable weight to making the phonologic separation between any two gismu as far apart as possible. This will help in keeping the two words separate in one's mind.
(The other problem I've had, in learning the deep gismu list, is
the inconsistency. For example while some things have source/location, some have composition (and I can see that, and don't necessarily have a problem with that), and some have both source and composition, those latter all have source first, then composition, EXCEPT rokci. While most things that have a to and from argument have it in the order "to" and "from", there are a few exceptions (ex. rinci and sputu). While most body parts that have three places have the body in x3, some don't, such as nazbi (possibly forgiveable, as the subpart is there), kerfa, rango (but compare cigla). Some measurements have subunits before the "by standard" piece, some after, etc. I know this has all been discussed elsewhere.)
--gejyspa
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
sel ter vel xel
John E Clifford <[email protected]> · 2009-11-23 11:27 UTC · Tiki post #8315 · reply to Tiki post #8292
The clump problem has been noted since at least 1960 on intelligibility grounds (which probably embraces learnabilty as well). Your idea wouldn't help much except to guarantee that all the possible similarities got in (with differentiation only in the second syllable, if at all). The inconsistent assignment of similar relations to different places -- and indeed, any rationale for what relations go where -- goes back to the original prospectus for Loglan, where JCB proposed a frequency test. Which was, of course, never actually carried out, since it is often hard to see what would count as evidence and where to get it.
Original Message ----
From: Michael Turniansky <[email protected]> To: [email protected] Sent: Thursday, June 4, 2009 10:29:02 AM Subject: [lojban] Re: sel ter vel xel
On Mon, Jun 1, 2009 at 11:22 AM, John E Clifford <[email protected]> wrote: > OK, I'll put this in the file for LoCCan3. It will pretty much kill the > 'easy to learn' 'feature' of the present system, but -- absent a test -- no > one seems to have believed that anyhow. I think this is the first > suggestion about phonolgy -- and immediately suggests the need to revise the > lujvo rules; any suggestions? >
I'm sure I haven't a clue what "LoCCan3" is, and I have REALLY no
desire to throw away all the aging brain cells I've already invested in learning lojban, but one of the phonological problems I've always had learning lojban is the of all the theoretical vastness of the gismu space, there is severe "clumping" in some areas, and other areas are completely unused. For example, there is ganra/grana/garna/gerna, xrani/xanri, cernba/cinba, tsina/tsani/tinsa, tinsa/rinsa/risna, racli/ralci, etc. etc. but not a single gismu with a pattern of *f*j*
- p*v* *v*v* *x*v* *z*x* or *z*z*, nor any gismu using any of more than
470 theoretically possible consonantal triples (in ANY order) such as {d,f,z} {d,s,z} {d,p,t}, {l,l,m}, {s,t,v} I know that this is driven by the gismu derivation paradigm, but I think any "reimagining" of lojban should give reasonable weight to making the phonologic separation between any two gismu as far apart as possible. This will help in keeping the two words separate in one's mind.
(The other problem I've had, in learning the deep gismu list, is
the inconsistency. For example while some things have source/location, some have composition (and I can see that, and don't necessarily have a problem with that), and some have both source and composition, those latter all have source first, then composition, EXCEPT rokci. While most things that have a to and from argument have it in the order "to" and "from", there are a few exceptions (ex. rinci and sputu). While most body parts that have three places have the body in x3, some don't, such as nazbi (possibly forgiveable, as the subpart is there), kerfa, rango (but compare cigla). Some measurements have subunits before the "by standard" piece, some after, etc. I know this has all been discussed elsewhere.)
--gejyspa
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.sel ter vel xel
Minimiscience · 2009-11-23 11:27 UTC · Tiki post #8316 · reply to Tiki post #8292
> LoCCan3 is the shadowy third version of "the logical language" (the CC means > "two consonants to be named later"). It exists, if at all, as a list of > "corrections" to "mistakes" in the first two verisons (the list for Loglan, > and probably Lojban, are out of date). Feel free to add your own. .skamyxatra
I would very much like to see this list, preferably as a website or page on the tiki. If you're taking suggestions right now, my two most well-formed complaints are that all of the cultural {gismu} should be removed (with the exception of "{lojbo}," the continental {gismu}, and possibly the {gismu} for the six source languages), and the metric/non-metric measurement words should be merged into generic {gismu} for each type of measurement with a single {gismu} meaning "metric" ("{metro}"?) added to the language.
mu'omi'e .kamymecraijun.
-- li'a .e'i ca vondei .i mi na'e pu'i kufra loi vondei
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
sel ter vel xel
John E Clifford <[email protected]> · 2009-11-23 11:27 UTC · Tiki post #8317 · reply to Tiki post #8292
Original Message ----
From: Minimiscience <[email protected]> To: [email protected] Sent: Thursday, June 4, 2009 4:16:58 PM Subject: [lojban] Re: sel ter vel xel
de'i li 04 pi'e 06 pi'e 2009 la'o fy. John E Clifford .fy. cusku zoi skamyxatra. > LoCCan3 is the shadowy third version of "the logical language" (the CC means > "two consonants to be named later"). It exists, if at all, as a list of > "corrections" to "mistakes" in the first two verisons (the list for Loglan, > and probably Lojban, are out of date). Feel free to add your own. .skamyxatra
I would very much like to see this list, preferably as a website or page on the tiki. If you're taking suggestions right now, my two most well-formed complaints are that all of the cultural {gismu} should be removed (with the exception of "{lojbo}," the continental {gismu}, and possibly the {gismu} for the six source languages), and the metric/non-metric measurement words should be merged into generic {gismu} for each type of measurement with a single {gismu} meaning "metric" ("{metro}"?) added to the language.
mu'omi'e .kamymecraijun.
-- li'a .e'i ca vondei .i mi na'e pu'i kufra loi vondei
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.sel ter vel xel
Adam Raizen <[email protected]> · 2009-11-23 11:27 UTC · Tiki post #8318 · reply to Tiki post #8292
> (The other problem I've had, in learning the deep gismu list, is > the inconsistency. For example while some things have > source/location, some have composition (and I can see that, and don't > necessarily have a problem with that), and some have both source and > composition, those latter all have source first, then composition, > EXCEPT rokci. While most things that have a to and from argument have > it in the order "to" and "from", there are a few exceptions (ex. rinci > and sputu). While most body parts that have three places have the > body in x3, some don't, such as nazbi (possibly forgiveable, as the > subpart is there), kerfa, rango (but compare cigla). Some > measurements have subunits before the "by standard" piece, some after, > etc. I know this has all been discussed elsewhere.) >
This is my other major pet-peeve with Lojban as it currently stands, making essentially unlearnable (at least correctly). Gismu places should be zealously cropped to contain only those places which are absolutely essential in casual conversation, and then cropped some more, no matter how necessary someone argues that they are logically or philosophically. No gismu should have more than 3 places. "By standard" places are going to be used approximately 1/1000 (wild guess) of the time that a gismu that has them is used (not to mention 'by epistemology', which will only be used in philosophical discussions conducted in Lojban). That is not anywhere near frequent enough for it to be retained in a living language.
-- Adam Raizen <[email protected]>
Got sente?sel ter vel xel
Stela Selckiku <[email protected]> · 2009-11-23 11:27 UTC · Tiki post #8320 · reply to Tiki post #8292
> Is it still completely out of the question to change just one little rafsi > so we can have 100% consistency instead of 99.9% consistency?
If you think that changing any small number of things will make Lojban
100% consistent, you have a lot to learn about Lojban. :)
> I just picture teaching my kids lojban and them saying "but dad, you said
> that there are no exceptions toe the rules in lojban, why is the rafsi of
> 'te' 'ter' when all the others are just themselves plus 'l'?".
There's no rules you can learn to generate rafsi, I'm afraid. You
have to memorize the rafsi. Some of them are sort of like the gismu,
some are sort of like cmavo, some are pulled out of someone's ass.
That's about all the structure you're going to find to it.
> I know it's a cosmetic thing but it does kind of stick in my head like a
> thorn ya' know? "sel, ter, vel, xel". Blech.
OK look, I'm probably just rationalizing, but here's how I think about it.
First, leave "vel" and "xel" out of it. Quick, what's the first lujvo that comes to mind with "vel" or "xel"? The first one that comes to my mind is: A complete blank. None at all. If I think for a while I can remember occasionally seeing "velsku" and "xelkla". But they're rare enough that it doesn't matter much at all what they sound like.
It's the complete opposite with "sel". It's hard to find lujvo that don't have "sel". People all the time refer to second place things as "sel" + the shortest rafsi they can find-- selkla, selsku, selcme. Those words are basically an accented "sel" with a few sounds tacked on the end that tell you what you're even talking about.
In between we have "ter", which is much less common than "sel", but much more common than "vel" and "xel". We've already got an excess of "sel" all over the place, putting the language in danger of having everything sound the same, so I find it a relief that there's a little bit of a different sound to "ter" in there.
Obviously it's not perfect spartan efficiency that to say the x2 and x3 of cmene we can say se cmene, selcmene, or selcme and te cmene, tercmene, or tercme. But Lojban is not logical in the old dry way of the philosophical languages, organizing everything into perfect rows. It turns out that a little bit of messiness, a little bit of diversity is necessary in order for a language to be practically useful. It might seem more orderly to have all the conversion rafsi sound the same, but I think it is more practical and aesthetic to hear and write a diversity of sounds.
People complain all the time about the complexity and quirkiness of Lojban's way of forming words, but there have been countless projects over centuries which have tried to invent logical orderly word-formation processes, and most of them are astoundingly ugly. There's a reason, though perhaps an illogical one, why Lojban's quirky lujvo succeeded where Ro's sterile efficiency failed. Of course it's easier to think of a simpler way for rafsi to go together. It's simple to just make everything even blocks, for instance. Then it's easy to split everything apart, because it's all the same. In Lojban everything is not all the same-- it's a quirky, weird little language.
That is why it's the first logical language which so many speakers
have come to love.
mu'o mi'e la stela se ckiku mi'e la .telselkik.
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
