Talk:Tiki forum archive/Forum 5/7907

From Lojban

Source: 2013 Tiki forum 5, thread #7907. Original authors, UTC times, post IDs, and reply-parent IDs are preserved. This is an archive, not an active article discussion.

Missing out obvious words

Missing out obvious words

Christopher Done <[email protected]> · 2009-02-05 06:33 UTC · Tiki post #7907

Some Lojban words that we use in casual conversation seem unnecessary.

An example is:

Person 1: {mi tavla} Person 2, response 1: {tavla ma} Person 2, response 2: {go'i ma} Person 2, response 3: {ma}

It seems that response 3 has obvious meaning. We can take it to different selbri places, too:

{tavla fi ma} => {go'i fi ma} => {fi ma}

Has this kind of usage been observed to be common in casual Lojban conversation? This kind of elision is acceptable for answers to questions:

Person 1: {do tavla fi ma} Person 2: {mi tavla fi la djan} => {tavla fi la djan} => {go'i fi la djan} => {la djan}

An example of pragmatism of this flavour, which I have seen recently, brought to my attention by Daniel Brockman, is {ja'a} and {na} (NA). Is {go'i} required when using these in response?

Person 1: {do tavla la djan} Person 2: {na go'i} or Person 2: {go'i}

This seems common on the Lojban IRC. But what about:

Person 1: {do tavla la djan} Person 2: {na} or Person 2: {ja'a}

Looking at the CLL (Chapter 19, Section 5), this is acceptable. To quote:

> The full list of non-bridi utterances suitable as answers to questions is: > any number of sumti (with elidable terminator ``vau, see Chapter 6<http://jbotcan.org/cllc/c6/s1.html>) > an ek or gihek (logical connectives, see Chapter 14<http://jbotcan.org/cllc/c14/s1.html>) > a number, or any mathematical expression placed in parentheses (see Chapter > 18 <http://jbotcan.org/cllc/c18/s1.html>) a bare ``na negator (to negate > some previously expressed bridi), or corresponding ``ja'a affirmer (see Chapter > 15 <http://jbotcan.org/cllc/c15/s1.html>) a relative clause (to modify > some previously expressed sumti, see Chapter 8<http://jbotcan.org/cllc/c8/s1.html>) > a prenex/topic (to modify some previously expressed bridi, see Chapter 16<http://jbotcan.org/cllc/c16/s1.html>) > linked arguments (beginning with ``be or ``bei and attached to some > previously expressed selbri, often in a description,see Chapter 5<http://jbotcan.org/cllc/c5/s1.html> > ) > > At the beginning of a text, the following non-bridi are also permitted: > one or more names (to indicate direct address without ``doi, see Chapter > 6 <http://jbotcan.org/cllc/c6/s1.html>) indicators (to express a > prevailing attitude, see Chapter 13 <http://jbotcan.org/cllc/c13/s1.html>) > ``nai (to vaguely negate something or other, see Chapter 15<http://jbotcan.org/cllc/c15/s1.html> > ) > > Where not needed for the expression of answers, most of these are made > grammatical for pragmatic reasons: people will say them in conversation, and > there is no reason to rule them out as ungrammatical merely because most of > them are vague. > See here for the page: http://jbotcan.org/cllc/c19/s5.html

So proceeding with the knowledge that many bridi-less answers are allowed, presumably because they are so *obvious*, it seems an interesting idea that questions can be bridi-less, *when obvious, as above*.

I haven't discovered anything in the CLL about bridi-less questions, this is why I'm asking here.

Thoughts?

Missing out obvious words

Jorge Llambías <[email protected]> · 2009-02-06 12:56 UTC · Tiki post #7908 · reply to Tiki post #7907

On Thu, Feb 5, 2009 at 3:31 AM, Christopher Done

<[email protected]> wrote: > > So proceeding with the knowledge that many bridi-less answers are allowed, > presumably because they are so obvious, it seems an interesting idea that > questions can be bridi-less, when obvious, as above.

I would call such fragmentary sentences "implicit-selbri", rather than "bridi-less". They can always be completed with "co'e" to get a formally complete bridi.

> I haven't discovered anything in the CLL about bridi-less questions, this is > why I'm asking here. > > Thoughts?

As long as they are understood, I don't see any problem with them.

A truly bridi-less question is something like "ui pei".

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.