Talk:Tiki forum archive/Forum 5/7676
Source: 2013 Tiki forum 5, thread #7676. Original authors, UTC times, post IDs, and reply-parent IDs are preserved. This is an archive, not an active article discussion.
Superfluous {tosmabru} check?
Superfluous {tosmabru} check?
Minimiscience · 2008-11-26 23:15 UTC · Tiki post #7676
I was just reading the {lujvo} creation algorithm in the Lojban Reference Grammar, attempting to convert it to Perl, when I noticed something that seemed to be unnecessary. CLL chapter 4, section 11, item 5 says:
Test all forms with one or more initial CVC-form rafsi --- with the pattern ``CVC ... CVC + X --- for ``tosmabru failure. X must either be a CVCCV long rafsi that happens to have a permissible initial pair as the consonant cluster, or is ***something which has caused a ``y-hyphen to be installed between the previous CVC and itself by one of the above rules.***
Note the highlighted part. The only two reasons that a 'y' hyphen would have been inserted was if (a) it came after a four-letter {rafsi}, in which case it would not be at the end of a sequence of CVC {rafsi}, or (b) it came in the middle of an impermissible consonant pair. However, an impermissible consonant pair clearly cannot be a valid initial consonant pair, and so the "joint" at that location would always cause no further hyphens in the word to be needed. Item 5a even explicitly states that the last joint is the last consonant of the CVC sequence plus the first consonant of the 'X' part, "*ignoring any ``y-hyphen before the X*", and so it can never be true in such a {lujvo} that all joints are initial consonant pairs. Thus, the {tosmabru} test will always indicate that a {lujvo} of the form "(CVC)* + 'y' + X" does not need any further hyphens, and so applying the test to such a {lujvo} in the first place is completely pointless. Is this true, or am I missing something very basic?
la'o gy. Minimiscience .gy.
-- do ganai ka'e tcidu dei gi djuno lo dukse
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
Superfluous {tosmabru} check?
" Jorge Llambías " <[email protected]> · 2008-11-26 23:43 UTC · Tiki post #7677 · reply to Tiki post #7676
> Thus, the {tosmabru} test will always > indicate that a {lujvo} of the form "(CVC)* + 'y' + X" does not need any > further hyphens, and so applying the test to such a {lujvo} in the first place > is completely pointless. Is this true, or am I missing something very basic?
Consider bab+lab+bla: bablabybla = ba blabybla
mu'o mi'e xorxes
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
Superfluous {tosmabru} check?
Minimiscience · 2008-11-27 00:06 UTC · Tiki post #7678 · reply to Tiki post #7676
> Consider bab+lab+bla: bablabybla = ba blabybla .skamyxatra
Good point, but that actually means that the {lujvo}-making algorithm as described in the CLL is wrong (or at least very poorly worded). As "bb" is not a valid initial consonant pair, the {tosmabru} test still says in §4.11.5b that no extra hyphens are needed, which is clearly wrong.
la'o gy. Minimiscience .gy.
-- no zo mi nenri zo bende
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
Superfluous {tosmabru} check?
" Jorge Llambías " <[email protected]> · 2008-11-27 00:43 UTC · Tiki post #7680 · reply to Tiki post #7676
> de'i li 26 pi'e 11 pi'e 2008 la'o fy. Jorge Llambías .fy. cusku zoi skamyxatra. >> Consider bab+lab+bla: bablabybla = ba blabybla > .skamyxatra > > Good point, but that actually means that the {lujvo}-making algorithm as > described in the CLL is wrong (or at least very poorly worded). As "bb" is not > a valid initial consonant pair, the {tosmabru} test still says in §4.11.5b that > no extra hyphens are needed, which is clearly wrong.
Yes, that "ignoring any ``y-hyphen before the X" doesn't seem to make any sense.
mu'o mi'e xorxes
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
Superfluous {tosmabru} check?
" Jorge Llambías " <[email protected]> · 2008-11-27 01:18 UTC · Tiki post #7681 · reply to Tiki post #7676
<http://www.lojban.org/tiki/tiki-index.php?page=CLL%2C+aka+Reference+Grammar%2C+Errata>
Chapter 4, section 11, 5a)
"Examine all the C/C consonant pairs that join the CVC rafsi, and also the pair between the last CVC and the X portion, ignoring any "y"-hyphen before the X."
should read instead:
"Examine all the C/C consonant pairs up to the first "y"-hyphen, or up to the end of the word in case there are no "y"-hyphens."
mu'o mi'e xorxes
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
Superfluous {tosmabru} check?
Minimiscience · 2008-11-27 01:34 UTC · Tiki post #7682 · reply to Tiki post #7676
> Chapter 4, section 11, 5a) > > "Examine all the C/C consonant pairs that join the CVC rafsi, and also > the pair between the last CVC and the X portion, ignoring any > "y"-hyphen before the X." > > should read instead: > > "Examine all the C/C consonant pairs up to the first "y"-hyphen, or up > to the end of the word in case there are no "y"-hyphens." .skamyxatra
That definitely makes more sense. ki'e sai
mu'omi'e la'o gy. Minimiscience .gy.
-- do ganai ka'e tcidu dei gi djuno lo dukse
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
Superfluous {tosmabru} check?
PierreAbbat · 2008-11-27 03:31 UTC · Tiki post #7683 · reply to Tiki post #7676
> coi logji jbopre > > Note the highlighted part. The only two reasons that a 'y' hyphen would > have been inserted was if (a) it came after a four-letter {rafsi}, in which > case it would not be at the end of a sequence of CVC {rafsi}, or (b) it > came in the middle of an impermissible consonant pair. However, an > impermissible consonant pair clearly cannot be a valid initial consonant > pair, and so the "joint" at that location would always cause no further > hyphens in the word to be needed. Item 5a even explicitly states that the > last joint is the last consonant of the CVC sequence plus the first > consonant of the 'X' part, "*ignoring any ``y-hyphen before the X*", and > so it can never be true in such a {lujvo} that all joints are initial > consonant pairs. Thus, the {tosmabru} test will always indicate that a > {lujvo} of the form "(CVC)* + 'y' + X" does not need any further hyphens, > and so applying the test to such a {lujvo} in the first place is completely > pointless. Is this true, or am I missing something very basic?
It is possible for 'y' to be required without the two rafsi having an impermissible consonant pair. Here is an example:
mi jbinytcadu mijybinytcadu
It is also possible for the type-3 fu'ivla algorithm in the Book to produce an invalid word, for the same reason. An example is "ler + djamo", which would be "lerndjamo" by the Book, but has to be "lerldjamo".
Pierre
To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected]
with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if
