Talk:Tiki forum archive/Forum 5/7378

From Lojban

Source: 2013 Tiki forum 5, thread #7378. Original authors, UTC times, post IDs, and reply-parent IDs are preserved. This is an archive, not an active article discussion.

le gusta co minde mutce

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-10-26 15:48 UTC · Tiki post #7378

Use this thread to discuss the le gusta co minde mutce page.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-10-26 15:48 UTC · Tiki post #7379 · reply to Tiki post #7378

coi ro do

Here's my first attempt at a short story translation:

http://www.lojban.org/tiki/tiki-index.php?page=le+gusta+co+minde+mutce&bl=n&saved_msg=y

It's a direct translation of a Japanese piece by Miyazawa Kenji. I intended to 1) use less shortened lujvos (e.g. {ckikykevna} instead of {kikyke'a}, except the like of {-gau} or {-kla}), 2) make use of as much cnima'o as to help register what I found to be the implicit emotional information carried by the Japanese attitudinal system, and 3) explore the experimental cmavo {sa'ei} since the original text is frequented by onomatopoeia.

An unofficial English translation can be found here (and this I think is governed by a rather compromised reading):

http://tonygonz.blogspot.com/2006/05/restaurant-of-many-orders-miyazawa.html

Feedbacks are welcome.

I also plan on translating another piece by Miyazawa titled "Night On The Milky Way Train".

mu'o mi'e tijlan


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-02 20:44 UTC · Tiki post #7464 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Sun, Oct 26, 2008 at 12:35 PM, tijlan <[email protected]> wrote:

> > Here's my first attempt at a short story translation: > > http://www.lojban.org/tiki/tiki-index.php?page=le+gusta+co+minde+mutce&bl=n&saved_msg=y

ua mutce xamgu .i xu do ponjo

> Feedbacks are welcome.

OK, here are some comments:

>> .i no sai zo'e ga'i vi cipni jonai vlilydanlu vau .oi

I think you want "ja" rather than "jonai" there.

>> da'i lo nu piso'o dantyfriti fi lo jirnydza ke pelxu betfymlana zo'u

"piso'o dantyfriti" is a sumti. Maybe "piso'omei dantyfriti"?

>> .i mi ja'eda'i lo mu'e tolcikna binxo cu nu citka djica

"nu citka kei djica"?

>> .i ko'a mu'e frumu

"ko'a co'i frumu", or "mu'e ko'a frumu".

>>.i bazi lo mu'e fi le tanbo cu punji le burcu kei ge ri sa'ei .vouf. ka bumru canci gi sa'ei .douf. brife mo'ine'i le kumfa

"ka bumru kei canci"?

>> .i lo du'u ganai da'i na sutra kenro bo zenba va'u loi glare selcidja gi ba tceraktu fasnu kei se smadi le reldza

kenro->kanro

>> .i .e'o ko vi punji le cnebydasrypijne .e le batknkafsa .e le kanlyblaci .e le jdinydakli .e ro lo drata jinme to sa'e lo jipnykinli

"batknkafsa"??? Is that cuff links? What about something like "xancykarli batke"?

>> lu go'i .ia .i ni'iku .uaru'e pleji vi ti xu ca lo nu cliva li'u

Why were they expecting to pay? Wasn't it supposed to be free? ("za'a le ti zdani cu ka'e gusta co nonjdima selfu mi'o")

>> .i vaku za'ure'u vorme poi ca'u ke'a pamei blaci patxu

"poi" needs a sumti to modify. Maybe "za'ure'u me lo vorme poi ...". Also, you probably want "pamei ke blaci patxu".

>> .i mu'i lo za'i ru'i se vasru le patxu kei ro le reldza tai lo zu'o gacrygau fi le flira fe lei kruji cu mipri citka ri

I think "za'o" (still contains, keeps on containing) is better than "ru'i" (contains without interruption).

"ro le relzda" is "each pair". Probably "ro le re nanmu" would be better.

>>.i .ii mi pupu'o ri'a kerlo skapyfenra

Probably needs re-wording, since it's not him that was about to be a crack. "mi zo'u pu pu'o ..." should work.

>>.i zu'unai mi nu co'a citka sutra .auku'i

"nu co'a citka kei sutra"?

>> .i ju'o ditcu me'i lo mentu be li pamu

I think: "lo mentu be li me'ipamu". "me'i lo mentu be li pamu" is "not all ten-minute intervals".

>> ti ka sarvanju .uanai pancydjacu

"ka sarvanju kei" or just "sarvanju pancydjacu"

>> .i ku'i ba'e caroi le reldza cu terpa gi'e mu'e simxu catlu le flira noi ba'o mutce co se gacri loi kruji

"caroi" is not grammatical. I use "ca lo ca krefu" for "this time".

Also, mu'e -> co'i

>> lu [...] .i ni'iku la'edi'u se smuni .y. jy. jy. jy. ja'o lo du'u my. my. mi'o ... li'u

"jy.jy.jy" and "my.my" are sumti that will fill a sumti place, and that final part is not grammatical because there's no selbri after du'u, so it can't really be in lu-li'u quotes. It's hard to stammer in Lojban and not meddle with the grammar.

>>.i sa'ei .gatagatat. ko'a tu'a le ti'a vorme catke troci

"cu catke troci"?

>> .i va za'ure'u vorme poi ke'a fe'ereroi se ckikykevna co barda

"vorme poi" -> "me lo vorme poi"

>> .i fi'isai ko ga'inai mo'i nenri

You need "do'u" after "fi'isai" if "ko" is meant to be the x1 of "nenri".

>> .i ji'asai mo'ito'o le ckikykevna ku re blanu kanlybolci sa'ei .kiorokioror. cu fa'a ti catlu

"fa'a ti" is a term, it can't come between "cu" and the selbri. You can just omit "cu" there, or move "fa'a ti" before "cu" or after "catlu".

>> .i ju'a le la jatna cusku tadji cu xlali

"le la jatna ku cusku tadji"

>> .i la jatna .io za'o za'i cutnybukpu dasni jeke dakfu jgari jeke tance mosra ke'e denpa tu'a do doi .io vitke

"za'i ... kei"

>> .i le pe le ckikykevna ku'o kanlybolci cu zisai to'o cliva

ku'o -> ge'u

>> .i le gerku ge ze'a ke cmoni clupyklama ne'i le kumfa gibabo fau lo mu'e za'ure'u pavykrixa kei sutra plipe fa'a le lamji vorme

kei -> cu

>>.i ri sa'ei .gatar. kalri binxo ja'e lo nu ro le gerku cu se sakci pe'a pa'o klama

"pa'o" (or any tag) can't be used as part of a tanru.

>> .i ne'i lo ze'o le vorme ku manku cu bacru lu sa'ei .niaaon.kuaan.gorgor. li'u

A tagged sumti can't be used in that position, but "pe ze'o le vorme ku" will work.

>> .i le kumfa sekai lo ka danmo cu mu'e canci

mu'e -> co'i

>> .i le reldza cu ri'a di'a menlykenro

kenro -> kanro

Nice work!

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-03 02:43 UTC · Tiki post #7465 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/2 Jorge Llambías <[email protected]>:

> On Sun, Oct 26, 2008 at 12:35 PM, tijlan <[email protected]> wrote: >> >> Here's my first attempt at a short story translation: >> >> http://www.lojban.org/tiki/tiki-index.php?page=le+gusta+co+minde+mutce&bl=n&saved_msg=y > > ua mutce xamgu .i xu do ponjo

ki'e .i na go'e .i mi ponbau kakne seja'e lo nu ze'u xabju la .tokion. ca lo citycedra

.i mi gleki lo nu lo mi nuntadni be la .lojban. cu se vanbi lo tai crepre doi .xorxes.


>>> .i no sai zo'e ga'i vi cipni jonai vlilydanlu vau .oi > > I think you want "ja" rather than "jonai" there.

My thought was: can a little bird (which was what I meant by {cipni}) be also a beast?


>>> da'i lo nu piso'o dantyfriti fi lo jirnydza ke pelxu betfymlana zo'u > > "piso'o dantyfriti" is a sumti. Maybe "piso'omei dantyfriti"?

My mistake. By {piso'o} I intended to mean "some of the bullets". I was ambitiously looking for a way to say it in a tense-like form.

Supposing {piso'omei dantyfriti} is a tanru, I think I'll go with that.


>>> .i mi ja'eda'i lo mu'e tolcikna binxo cu nu citka djica > > "nu citka kei djica"?

I knew about the convention, but I wasn't clear about why NU's scope was considered that long. If the left-grouping applies to NU too, shouldn't {nu citka} without the delimiter be a separate seltau for {djica}?


>>> .i ko'a mu'e frumu > > "ko'a co'i frumu", or "mu'e ko'a frumu".

Is {mu'e frumu} not a valid selbri?


>>> lu go'i .ia .i ni'iku .uaru'e pleji vi ti xu ca lo nu cliva li'u > > Why were they expecting to pay?

They weren't, before they entered the room. My interpretation is: Now that they are asked to leave their wallets before they sit at the table, ko'a has started re-questioning the possibility of payment. And ko'e seconds that guess. This shared guesswork eventually solidifies. Yet perhaps {go'i la'a} sounds a bit too strong than it should be (should be closer to "It seems so"). After all, they are hungry to the point where they feel they are about to mentally fail. Their brains not working right can be one apologetic ;)


>>> .i ku'i ba'e caroi le reldza cu terpa gi'e mu'e simxu catlu le flira noi ba'o mutce co se gacri loi kruji > > "caroi" is not grammatical. I use "ca lo ca krefu" for "this time".

I was quite unsure about {caroi} myself. {ca lo ca krefu} looks a bit wordy but I like the idea. Will be fixed. Thank you.


mu'o mi'e tijlan


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-03 02:43 UTC · Tiki post #7466 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/2 Jorge Llambías <[email protected]>:

> On Sun, Oct 26, 2008 at 12:35 PM, tijlan <[email protected]> wrote: >> >> Here's my first attempt at a short story translation: >> >> http://www.lojban.org/tiki/tiki-index.php?page=le+gusta+co+minde+mutce&bl=n&saved_msg=y > > ua mutce xamgu .i xu do ponjo

ki'e .i na go'e .i mi ponbau kakne seja'e lo nu ze'u xabju la .tokion. ca lo citycedra

.i mi gleki lo nu lo mi nuntadni be la .lojban. cu se vanbi lo tai crepre doi .xorxes.


>>> .i no sai zo'e ga'i vi cipni jonai vlilydanlu vau .oi > > I think you want "ja" rather than "jonai" there.

My thought was: can a little bird (which was what I meant by {cipni}) be also a beast?


>>> da'i lo nu piso'o dantyfriti fi lo jirnydza ke pelxu betfymlana zo'u > > "piso'o dantyfriti" is a sumti. Maybe "piso'omei dantyfriti"?

My mistake. By {piso'o} I intended to mean "some of the bullets". I was ambitiously looking for a way to say it in a tense-like form.

Supposing {piso'omei dantyfriti} is a tanru, I think I'll go with that.


>>> .i mi ja'eda'i lo mu'e tolcikna binxo cu nu citka djica > > "nu citka kei djica"?

I knew about the convention, but I wasn't clear about why NU's scope was considered that long. If the left-grouping applies to NU too, shouldn't {nu citka} without the delimiter be a separate seltau for {djica}?


>>> .i ko'a mu'e frumu > > "ko'a co'i frumu", or "mu'e ko'a frumu".

Is {mu'e frumu} not a valid selbri?


>>> lu go'i .ia .i ni'iku .uaru'e pleji vi ti xu ca lo nu cliva li'u > > Why were they expecting to pay?

They weren't, before they entered the room. My interpretation is: Now that they are asked to leave their wallets before they sit at the table, ko'a has started re-questioning the possibility of payment. And ko'e seconds that guess. This shared guesswork eventually solidifies. Yet perhaps {go'i la'a} sounds a bit too strong than it should be (should be closer to "It seems so"). After all, they are hungry to the point where they feel they are about to mentally fail. Their brains not working right can be one apologetic ;)


>>> .i ku'i ba'e caroi le reldza cu terpa gi'e mu'e simxu catlu le flira noi ba'o mutce co se gacri loi kruji > > "caroi" is not grammatical. I use "ca lo ca krefu" for "this time".

I was quite unsure about {caroi} myself. {ca lo ca krefu} looks a bit wordy but I like the idea. Will be fixed. Thank you.


mu'o mi'e tijlan


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

PierreAbbat · 2008-11-03 04:02 UTC · Tiki post #7467 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Sunday 26 October 2008 11:35:57 tijlan wrote:

> coi ro do > > Here's my first attempt at a short story translation: > > http://www.lojban.org/tiki/tiki-index.php?page=le+gusta+co+minde+mutce&bl=n >&saved_msg=y > > It's a direct translation of a Japanese piece by Miyazawa Kenji. I > intended to 1) use less shortened lujvos (e.g. {ckikykevna} instead of > {kikyke'a}, except the like of {-gau} or {-kla}), 2) make use of as > much cnima'o as to help register what I found to be the implicit > emotional information carried by the Japanese attitudinal system, and > 3) explore the experimental cmavo {sa'ei} since the original text is > frequented by onomatopoeia. > > An unofficial English translation can be found here (and this I think > is governed by a rather compromised reading): > > http://tonygonz.blogspot.com/2006/05/restaurant-of-many-orders-miyazawa.htm >l > > Feedbacks are welcome.

"lo nanca be li 1924" means "1924 years"; you want "le 1924moi nanca".

jirnydza: If you mean "deer", that's "mirli". But I've seen a tongue twister "kamoshika mo shika mo shika da ga", "the serow and the shika are both deer", and the serow is actually a goat-antelope. What's the Japanese word here mean?

pevymoklu: "y" isn't needed.

Maybe more later...

Pierre


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-03 12:00 UTC · Tiki post #7470 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/3 Pierre Abbat <[email protected]>:

> "lo nanca be li 1924" means "1924 years"; you want "le 1924moi nanca".

je'e


> jirnydza: If you mean "deer", that's "mirli". But I've seen a tongue > twister "kamoshika mo shika mo shika da ga", "the serow and the shika are > both deer", and the serow is actually a goat-antelope. What's the Japanese > word here mean?

You're right. Originally it's "shika" and for that I should have used "mirli".

As for the twister, it's partly due to the irony that kamoshika (Bovidae) and shika (Cervidae) are biologically distant but lexically close. It can translate as:

kamoshika - mo | shika - mo | || shika - da

 | ga

la .kamomirlin. - ku ji'a | lo mirli - ku ji'a | zo'u || mirli (pe'a) - (ju'a) | ku'i


ki'e

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-03 12:04 UTC · Tiki post #7471 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Sun, Nov 2, 2008 at 11:41 PM, tijlan <[email protected]> wrote:

> 2008/11/2 Jorge Llambías <[email protected]>: > >>>> .i no sai zo'e ga'i vi cipni jonai vlilydanlu vau .oi >> >> I think you want "ja" rather than "jonai" there. > > My thought was: can a little bird (which was what I meant by {cipni}) > be also a beast?

Even if nothing could be both cipni and vlilydanlu (and I'm not sure that's true) I would still prefer "ja", simply because it's easier to understand. After all, the point is just that there aren't any cipni, and that there aren't any vlilydanlu.


>>>> da'i lo nu piso'o dantyfriti fi lo jirnydza ke pelxu betfymlana zo'u >> >> "piso'o dantyfriti" is a sumti. Maybe "piso'omei dantyfriti"? > > My mistake. By {piso'o} I intended to mean "some of the bullets". I > was ambitiously looking for a way to say it in a tense-like form. > > Supposing {piso'omei dantyfriti} is a tanru, I think I'll go with that.

It's a tanru, yes. {friti so'o lo danti lo jirnydza ke pelxu betfymlana} would be more straightforward.

>>>> .i mi ja'eda'i lo mu'e tolcikna binxo cu nu citka djica >> >> "nu citka kei djica"? > > I knew about the convention, but I wasn't clear about why NU's scope > was considered that long.

NU will grab a whole sentence after it, in this case the sentence {citka djica}

> If the left-grouping applies to NU too, > shouldn't {nu citka} without the delimiter be a separate seltau for > {djica}?

The left grouping applies to the {NU ... KEI} tanru unit. NU by itself is not a tanru unit, it converts a whole sentence that follows into a tanru unit.


>>>> .i ko'a mu'e frumu >> >> "ko'a co'i frumu", or "mu'e ko'a frumu". > > Is {mu'e frumu} not a valid selbri?

{ko'a mu'e frumu} is a grammatical sentence, but it says that ko'a (a man) is an event of frowning.

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-03 12:16 UTC · Tiki post #7472 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/3 Jorge Llambías <[email protected]>

> >>>> .i ko'a mu'e frumu > >> > >> "ko'a co'i frumu", or "mu'e ko'a frumu". > > > > Is {mu'e frumu} not a valid selbri? > > > {ko'a mu'e frumu} is a grammatical sentence, but it says that ko'a (a > man) is an event of frowning.


Ah ;)


Once again, thank you for your attention.

le gusta co minde mutce

PierreAbbat · 2008-11-03 13:37 UTC · Tiki post #7474 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Monday 03 November 2008 06:57:13 tijlan wrote:

> As for the twister, it's partly due to the irony that kamoshika (Bovidae) > and shika (Cervidae) are biologically distant but lexically close. It can > translate as: > > kamoshika - mo | shika - mo | || shika - da > > | ga > > la .kamomirlin. - ku ji'a | lo mirli - ku ji'a | zo'u || mirli (pe'a) - > (ju'a) | ku'i

Well the other part, "tashika ashika wa shika de wa nai," is about the sea lion, which isn't even an ungulate. The serow, like the deer, is a ruminant ungulate with head appendages.

Pierre


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

PierreAbbat · 2008-11-08 04:16 UTC · Tiki post #7520 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Sunday 26 October 2008 11:35:57 tijlan wrote:

> no sai zo'e ga'i vi cipni jonai vlilydanlu

"zo'e ga'i", IIRR, means that the speaker feels haughtiness toward zo'e, which doesn't make much sense.

I think "vlilydanlu" should be "mabru". A deer, mentioned in the next utterance, isn't what I'd call a vlilydanlu, although the act of shooting a deer is certainly vlile. Maybe it could be "cicymabru".

> .ei mutce pluka ba'a

"ei" doesn't make much sense. "As to offering a few bullets to the side of a deer's belly, I am *obliged* that it would be very pleasing, which I look forward to."

> cmana condi

Is that a lake or depression on a mountaintop?

> flirytcima

face-weather?

> cmanyjipci

mountain-chicken? The English translation says "game birds". What's the original say?

> .a'inaisai .i ti to'eki'unai lo za'i tai vanbi ce'u kei ca'a kagni stuzi > zo'e

I can't quite make sense of this. "Not despite being an environment of this, it actually is a corporation site"?

> ni'i ma fe'eso'iroi vorme

"ni'i" means a logical reason. One of the other whys probably would make more sense.

...skipping over text I may check later...

> ne'i lo ze'o le vorme ku manku cu bacru lu > sa'ei .niaaon.kuaan.gorgor. > li'u

Did the dogs say "sa'ei", or did they just say "niaaon.kuaan.gorgor"? I suspect the latter, which is grammatical according to jbofi'e.

> .gasagasas

I think that should be "gasagasag" or "gasagas". Adding an "s" at the end breaks the pattern.

Pierre


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-08 09:30 UTC · Tiki post #7521 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/8 Pierre Abbat <[email protected]>

> On Sunday 26 October 2008 11:35:57 tijlan wrote: > > no sai zo'e ga'i vi cipni jonai vlilydanlu > > "zo'e ga'i", IIRR, means that the speaker feels haughtiness toward zo'e, > which > doesn't make much sense.


Oh, it seems I got it wrong all the way. This "zo'e" should be an object of the speaker's contempt. On the contrary, the first message on the first door, which I started with "doi ro do ga'i", should reflect the honorific speech. So "zo'e ga'inai" is the right one?


I think "vlilydanlu" should be "mabru". A deer, mentioned in the next > utterance, isn't what I'd call a vlilydanlu, although the act of shooting a > deer is certainly vlile. Maybe it could be "cicymabru".


Originally "kemono", it should translate to something like "beast" in English. It's meant to be a contrast to "cipni" in fierceness. The speaker is emphasizing the absence of objects to hunt by referring to a wide range from "birds" to "beasts". A deer can be somewhere between the two polarities.


> .ei mutce pluka ba'a > > "ei" doesn't make much sense. "As to offering a few bullets to the side of > a > deer's belly, I am *obliged* that it would be very pleasing, which I look > forward to."


He is feeling *non-freedom* ("einainai") in the sense that it must be the case that, if he shoots a deer, it will very please him. And this pleasure is what he's looking forward to.


> cmana condi > > Is that a lake or depression on a mountaintop?


Originally "yama-oku" ("mountain-deep/inside"), it means that the x1 is a place you would reach if you walk for some time toward the center of a mountain or of a group of mountains. I had in mind something like this: 1.jpg


> flirytcima > > face-weather?


Originally "kao-iro" ("face-colour"), it's based on the idea that faces are expressive of psychological climate.


> cmanyjipci > > mountain-chicken? The English translation says "game birds". What's the > original say?


"Yama-dori" ("mountain-bird"), or "copper pheasant" ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copper_Pheasant). I wanted to avoid using "cipni", which is too general while "copper phesant" is specific enough, and which might cause a confusion with the earlier "cipni", the one the guys are looking for in the mountain.

Any suggestion?


> .a'inaisai .i ti to'eki'unai lo za'i tai vanbi ce'u kei ca'a kagni stuzi > > zo'e > > I can't quite make sense of this. "Not despite being an environment of > this, > it actually is a corporation site"?


"to'eki'unai" is "not prevented by reason ..." ("to'eki'u" being "prevented by reason ..."). Which gives "despite being surrounded by such an environment" for the sumtcita.

By "kagni" I meant "business". Maybe "cuntu" is better.

The speaker is surprised by the fact that, in the midst of such an empty mountain(s) (no birds, no beasts), there is actually a business (restaurant) going on.


> ni'i ma fe'eso'iroi vorme > > "ni'i" means a logical reason. One of the other whys probably would make > more > sense.


The speaker is not questioning a specific why. And, in my opinion, "ni'i" is a generic one, encompassing the other whys, like "nu" is to the other NUs. The sentence can be rephrased as:

ma nibli lo nu fe'eso'iroi vorme

This "ma" can be answered by either "krinu" or "mukti" or "rinka" or "se jalge", depending on what it actually turns out to be.


> ne'i lo ze'o le vorme ku manku cu bacru lu > > sa'ei .niaaon.kuaan.gorgor. > > li'u > > Did the dogs say "sa'ei", or did they just say "niaaon.kuaan.gorgor"? I > suspect the latter, which is grammatical according to jbofi'e. >

Is "sa'a" within "lu ... li'u" considered to be an actual part of the quoted utterance? I think not. If something can be skipped over like that, so should "sa'ei" be too, shouldn't it? And it's an experimental cmavo; what may be obvious to humans may not already be so to jbofi'e.


> .gasagasas > > I think that should be "gasagasag" or "gasagas". Adding an "s" at the end > breaks the pattern.


Originally "gasagasa", it's one of the Japanese ways of expressing the sounds of friction/scraping/rubbing, along with "sarasara", "zarazara", "sharishari", "fusafusa", "pasapasa", and so forth. As you can see, "s" is more common than "g" for the sounds of this kind. Other justifications are: phonetically, "s" in both Japanese and Lojban is fricative, which conceptually parallels to the fact that what "gasagasa" represents is the friction of the grass; and the word for "grass" in Lojban begins with an "s"

)


mu'o mi'e tijlan

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-08 18:33 UTC · Tiki post #7525 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Sat, Nov 8, 2008 at 1:07 AM, Pierre Abbat <[email protected]> wrote:

> >> .ei mutce pluka ba'a > > "ei" doesn't make much sense. "As to offering a few bullets to the side of a > deer's belly, I am *obliged* that it would be very pleasing, which I look > forward to."

I think ".ei" indicates how the speaker feels things ought to be. I read it as: "As to offering a few bullets to the side of a deer's belly, it ought to be very pleasing, I expect."

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-08 19:02 UTC · Tiki post #7527 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Sat, Nov 8, 2008 at 6:22 AM, tijlan <[email protected]> wrote:

> > The speaker is not questioning a specific why. And, in my opinion, "ni'i" is > a generic one, encompassing the other whys, like "nu" is to the other NUs. > The sentence can be rephrased as: > > ma nibli lo nu fe'eso'iroi vorme > > This "ma" can be answered by either "krinu" or "mukti" or "rinka" or "se > jalge", depending on what it actually turns out to be.

I would have said "ki'u ma" is the most general one, "what is the explanation for ...?", and not "from what can we deduce that ...?" which is what "ni'i ma" asks. I guess a logical entailment can also work as an explanation: All Russian-style buildings have many doors. This is a Russian-style building. Therefore, this building has many doors. That's the kind of answer provided, so "ni'i ma" is not ncessarily wrong, but I don't see that reasons, motives and physical causes can be logical entailments.

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

PierreAbbat · 2008-11-09 02:56 UTC · Tiki post #7528 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Saturday 08 November 2008 04:22:48 tijlan wrote:

> 2008/11/8 Pierre Abbat <[email protected]> > > > On Sunday 26 October 2008 11:35:57 tijlan wrote: > > > no sai zo'e ga'i vi cipni jonai vlilydanlu > > > > "zo'e ga'i", IIRR, means that the speaker feels haughtiness toward zo'e, > > which > > doesn't make much sense. > > Oh, it seems I got it wrong all the way. This "zo'e" should be an object of > the speaker's contempt. On the contrary, the first message on the first > door, which I started with "doi ro do ga'i", should reflect the honorific > speech. So "zo'e ga'inai" is the right one?

I'm not sure which way "ga'i" goes, but it seems strange to honor or contempt a word that's just a placeholder.

> Originally "kemono", it should translate to something like "beast" in > English. It's meant to be a contrast to "cipni" in fierceness. The speaker > is emphasizing the absence of objects to hunt by referring to a wide range > from "birds" to "beasts". A deer can be somewhere between the two > polarities.

Hmm, there are vlilycpi also, such as eagles and shrikes. I'm not sure what word to use for "kemono", but "bi'i' may make sense between them.

> Originally "kao-iro" ("face-colour"), it's based on the idea that faces are > expressive of psychological climate.

I think that's a good one.

> "Yama-dori" ("mountain-bird"), or "copper pheasant" ( > http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copper_Pheasant). I wanted to avoid using > "cipni", which is too general while "copper phesant" is specific enough, > and which might cause a confusion with the earlier "cipni", the one the > guys are looking for in the mountain. > > Any suggestion?

"ma'arjipci" is good. Could you check how wide a taxon it should refer to (just the Copper Pheasant, or the genus, or any pheasant) and add it to jbovlaste? I'll do the same with "fi'orxruki", which I made up many moons ago.

> > ni'i ma fe'eso'iroi vorme > > > > "ni'i" means a logical reason. One of the other whys probably would make > > more > > sense. > > The speaker is not questioning a specific why. And, in my opinion, "ni'i" > is a generic one, encompassing the other whys, like "nu" is to the other > NUs. The sentence can be rephrased as: > > ma nibli lo nu fe'eso'iroi vorme > > This "ma" can be answered by either "krinu" or "mukti" or "rinka" or "se > jalge", depending on what it actually turns out to be.

I agree with xorxes that "ki'u" is the most general. I'd like to hear a Russian's opinion though. Russian has three words for "why".

> Is "sa'a" within "lu ... li'u" considered to be an actual part of the > quoted utterance? I think not. If something can be skipped over like that, > so should "sa'ei" be too, shouldn't it? And it's an experimental cmavo; > what may be obvious to humans may not already be so to jbofi'e.

"sa'a" marks the previous word as not being part of the quoted utterance; "sa'ei" marks the next word as being an ideophone. You could say "sa'ei sa'a niaaon.kuaan.gorgor", but that sounds like the dog uttered an ideophone and forgot to mark it as such. The dog was just making noises. So I think that dropping "sa'a" is better. In the sentences that are bare quotes, without "le co'e cu cusku", "sa'ei" should be left in.

phma


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-09 12:43 UTC · Tiki post #7532 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/9 Pierre Abbat <[email protected]>

> On Saturday 08 November 2008 04:22:48 tijlan wrote: > > 2008/11/8 Pierre Abbat <[email protected]> > > > > > On Sunday 26 October 2008 11:35:57 tijlan wrote: > > > > no sai zo'e ga'i vi cipni jonai vlilydanlu > > > > > > "zo'e ga'i", IIRR, means that the speaker feels haughtiness toward > zo'e, > > > which > > > doesn't make much sense. > > > > Oh, it seems I got it wrong all the way. This "zo'e" should be an object > of > > the speaker's contempt. On the contrary, the first message on the first > > door, which I started with "doi ro do ga'i", should reflect the honorific > > speech. So "zo'e ga'inai" is the right one? > > I'm not sure which way "ga'i" goes, but it seems strange to honor or > contempt > a word that's just a placeholder.


It's a placeholder for the concept "something which are bird(s) and/or beast(s)" (I changed "jonai" to "ja"). When the speaker utters the word "zo'e", he is having this concept or image in mind. And this image provokes him into feeling a contempt. So, at least on the speaker's part, it's not unnatural if a UI is put right after a word the referent of which may not be immediately obvious to the reader.

After all, every word is a word. If "zo'e ga'i cipni" is meaningless, so must be "le .iu cipni" or "le cipni .iu" too, since both "le" and "cipni" are words.


> > Originally "kemono", it should translate to something like "beast" in > > English. It's meant to be a contrast to "cipni" in fierceness. The > speaker > > is emphasizing the absence of objects to hunt by referring to a wide > range > > from "birds" to "beasts". A deer can be somewhere between the two > > polarities. > > > Hmm, there are vlilycpi also, such as eagles and shrikes.


It depends on the fauna in which the speaker/narrator is contextualized, or the epistemological condition thereby. As for "swan", for example, it's not necessary for British people to always assume "there are white ones and black ones", since black swans are uncommon in Britain. Likewise, it need not be the case that the characters in the story anticipate the existence of "vlilycpi" in this particular region of mountains if they already know that such kind of birds is anyway very uncommon in the region.

I'm not sure what > word to use for "kemono", but "bi'i' may make sense between them.


If that can increase the readability, I'm pleased to fix it.


> > "Yama-dori" ("mountain-bird"), or "copper pheasant" ( > > http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copper_Pheasant). I wanted to avoid using > > "cipni", which is too general while "copper phesant" is specific enough, > > and which might cause a confusion with the earlier "cipni", the one the > > guys are looking for in the mountain. > > > > Any suggestion? > > > "ma'arjipci" is good. Could you check how wide a taxon it should refer to > (just the Copper Pheasant, or the genus, or any pheasant) and add it to > jbovlaste? I'll do the same with "fi'orxruki", which I made up many moons > ago.


Both "jipci" and "ma'arjipci" are of the family Phasianidae, the latter's particularity being the genus Syrmaticus and the species Syrmaticus Soemmerringii. I couldn't confirm whether the quality "ma'a-" should apply to Syrmaticus, so I defined "ma'arjipci" as Syrmaticus Soemmerringii:

http://jbovlaste.lojban.org/dict/ma%27arjipci

Isn't a corresponding Latin/Greek fu'ivla also desirable?


> > Is "sa'a" within "lu ... li'u" considered to be an actual part of the > > quoted utterance? I think not. If something can be skipped over like > that, > > so should "sa'ei" be too, shouldn't it? And it's an experimental cmavo; > > what may be obvious to humans may not already be so to jbofi'e. > > > "sa'a" marks the previous word as not being part of the quoted > utterance;"sa'ei" marks the next word as being an ideophone. You could > say "sa'ei sa'a niaaon.kuaan.gorgor", but that sounds like the dog uttered > an > ideophone and forgot to mark it as such. The dog was just making noises. So > I > think that dropping "sa'a" is better. In the sentences that are bare > quotes, > without "le co'e cu cusku", "sa'ei" should be left in.


Can't a word make itself editorial or metalinguistic? "sei" already seems to do that as in "lu sei la alis pensi mi zvati ma li'u"? If "sei" can automatically be not part of the original quotation, why not "sa'ei" too?

(BTW the sound is meant to be of the cats, who have been hiding in that last room and are now being attacked by the dogs.)


mu'o mi'e tijlan

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-09 12:43 UTC · Tiki post #7533 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/8 Jorge Llambías <[email protected]>

> On Sat, Nov 8, 2008 at 6:22 AM, tijlan <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > The speaker is not questioning a specific why. And, in my opinion, "ni'i" > is > > a generic one, encompassing the other whys, like "nu" is to the other > NUs. > > The sentence can be rephrased as: > > > > ma nibli lo nu fe'eso'iroi vorme > > > > This "ma" can be answered by either "krinu" or "mukti" or "rinka" or "se > > jalge", depending on what it actually turns out to be. > > I would have said "ki'u ma" is the most general one, "what is the > explanation for ...?", and not "from what can we deduce that ...?" > which is what "ni'i ma" asks. I guess a logical entailment can also > work as an explanation: All Russian-style buildings have many doors. > This is a Russian-style building. Therefore, this building has many > doors. That's the kind of answer provided, so "ni'i ma" is not > ncessarily wrong, but I don't see that reasons, motives and physical > causes can be logical entailments. > > mu'o mi'e xorxes > > > To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] > with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if > you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help. > > I co'a understand more tu'a "ki'u" & "ni'i", thank you.

mi'e tijlan

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-09 17:40 UTC · Tiki post #7535 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Sat, Nov 8, 2008 at 11:54 PM, Pierre Abbat <[email protected]> wrote:

> > I'm not sure which way "ga'i" goes,

I'm never sure about that either. I think in this case it's "zo'e ga'i" when talking about those lowly animals, and "do ga'inai" when addressig someone of higher rank. So "ga'i"/"ga'inai" marks the rank of the speaker as higher/lower than the other, whereas "io"/"ionai" marks the attitude of the speaker towards someone else, a slight difference in perspective.

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

PierreAbbat · 2008-11-09 18:00 UTC · Tiki post #7536 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Sunday 09 November 2008 12:37:40 Jorge Llambías wrote:

> On Sat, Nov 8, 2008 at 11:54 PM, Pierre Abbat <[email protected]> wrote: > > I'm not sure which way "ga'i" goes, > > I'm never sure about that either. I think in this case it's "zo'e > ga'i" when talking about those lowly animals, and "do ga'inai" when > addressig someone of higher rank. So "ga'i"/"ga'inai" marks the rank > of the speaker as higher/lower than the other, whereas "io"/"ionai" > marks the attitude of the speaker towards someone else, a slight > difference in perspective.

So a farmer with a worm bin could say "curnu ga'i .io", meaning he respects the worms, though regarding them as lowly. Right?

Pierre


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-09 18:21 UTC · Tiki post #7538 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/9 Pierre Abbat <[email protected]>

> On Sunday 09 November 2008 12:37:40 Jorge Llambías wrote: > > On Sat, Nov 8, 2008 at 11:54 PM, Pierre Abbat <[email protected]> > wrote: > > > I'm not sure which way "ga'i" goes, > > > > I'm never sure about that either. I think in this case it's "zo'e > > ga'i" when talking about those lowly animals, and "do ga'inai" when > > addressig someone of higher rank. So "ga'i"/"ga'inai" marks the rank > > of the speaker as higher/lower than the other, whereas "io"/"ionai" > > marks the attitude of the speaker towards someone else, a slight > > difference in perspective. > > So a farmer with a worm bin could say "curnu ga'i .io", meaning he respects > the worms, though regarding them as lowly. Right?


"ga'i" comes before "io", so I would read it as meaning he feels haughtiness in relation to the worms and at the same time respecting that circumstance in which haughtiness is felt by himself (not necessarily respecting the worms themselves).

mu'o mi'e tijlan

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-09 19:35 UTC · Tiki post #7539 · reply to Tiki post #7378

> I would have said "ki'u ma" is the most general one, "what is the

> explanation for ...?", and not "from what can we deduce that ...?" > which is what "ni'i ma" asks. I guess a logical entailment can also > work as an explanation: All Russian-style buildings have many doors. > This is a Russian-style building. Therefore, this building has many > doors. That's the kind of answer provided, so "ni'i ma" is not > ncessarily wrong, but I don't see that reasons, motives and physical > causes can be logical entailments.

I've always thought that {se ja'e ma} is the most general version. It's just "as a result of", without specifying what kind of result. -- Adam Lopresto http://cec.wustl.edu/~adam/

You can't get a leopard to change his spots. In fact, now that I come to think of it, you can't really get a leopard to appreciate the notion that it

  • has* spots. You can explain it carefully to the leopard, but it will just sit

there looking at you, knowing that you are made of meat. After a while it will perhaps kill you.

    --Geoffrey K. Pullum


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-10 16:31 UTC · Tiki post #7540 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Sun, Nov 9, 2008 at 4:34 PM, Adam D. Lopresto <[email protected]> wrote:

> > I've always thought that {se ja'e ma} is the most general version. It's > just > "as a result of", without specifying what kind of result.

I think {se jalge} definitely covers {rinka}, but I'm not sure it covers all kinds of {mukti}. A motive can be an event that is (potentially) in the future of the event it motivates. Can a result occur before what it results from? For example:

 lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne cu mukti lo nu mi klama le zarci
 I will buy butter motivates I go to the market.
 I go to the market to buy butter.
 lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne cu krinu lo nu mi klama le zarci
 I will buy butter is the reason I go to the market.
 I go to the market because I will buy butter.

both sound acceptable. I'm not sure about:

 ? lo nu mi klama le zarci cu jalge lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne
 ? I go to the market is the resut of I will buy butter.

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-10 17:20 UTC · Tiki post #7541 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/10 Jorge Llambías <[email protected]>:

> On Sun, Nov 9, 2008 at 4:34 PM, Adam D. Lopresto <[email protected]> wrote: >> >> I've always thought that {se ja'e ma} is the most general version. It's >> just >> "as a result of", without specifying what kind of result. > > I think {se jalge} definitely covers {rinka}, but I'm not sure it > covers all kinds of {mukti}. A motive can be an event that is > (potentially) in the future of the event it motivates. Can a result > occur before what it results from? For example: > > lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne cu mukti lo nu mi klama le zarci > I will buy butter motivates I go to the market. > I go to the market to buy butter. > > lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne cu krinu lo nu mi klama le zarci > I will buy butter is the reason I go to the market. > I go to the market because I will buy butter. > > both sound acceptable. I'm not sure about: > >  ? lo nu mi klama le zarci cu jalge lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne >  ? I go to the market is the resut of I will buy butter.

In this case I think it's essential that we retain the "lo nu" parts as we interpret the sentences:

lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne cu mukti lo nu mi klama le zarci
The (ideal) event "I will buy butter" motivates the (actual) event "I

go to the market".

lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne cu krinu lo nu mi klama le zarci
The (ideal) event "I will buy butter" justifies the (actual) event "I

go to the market".

lo nu mi klama le zarci cu jalge lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne
The (actual) event "I go to the market" results from the (ideal)

event "I will buy butter".


mu'o mi'e tijlan


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-10 17:39 UTC · Tiki post #7542 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Mon, Nov 10, 2008 at 2:17 PM, tijlan <[email protected]> wrote:

> > In this case I think it's essential that we retain the "lo nu" parts > as we interpret the sentences: > > lo nu mi klama le zarci cu jalge lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne > The (actual) event "I go to the market" results from the (ideal) > event "I will buy butter".

That's what I'm not sure about. Can an actual, present event be the result of an ideal, future event?

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-10 17:55 UTC · Tiki post #7543 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/10 Jorge Llambías <[email protected]>:

> On Mon, Nov 10, 2008 at 2:17 PM, tijlan <[email protected]> wrote: >> >> In this case I think it's essential that we retain the "lo nu" parts >> as we interpret the sentences: >> >> lo nu mi klama le zarci cu jalge lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne >> The (actual) event "I go to the market" results from the (ideal) >> event "I will buy butter". > > That's what I'm not sure about. Can an actual, present event be the > result of an ideal, future event?

Being ideal doesn't necessarily mean being incapable of being an antecedent. For clarity, let me specify these general "nu"s:

lo zu'o mi klama le zarci cu jalge lo si'o mi ba te vecnu lo matne

There is an idea of me buying butter to begin with, and then, as a result, there is an action of me going to the market.


mu'o mi'e tijlan


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-10 18:33 UTC · Tiki post #7544 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Mon, Nov 10, 2008 at 2:53 PM, tijlan <[email protected]> wrote:

> > Being ideal doesn't necessarily mean being incapable of being an > antecedent.

Right, as mukti and krinu show.

>For clarity, let me specify these general "nu"s: > > lo zu'o mi klama le zarci cu jalge lo si'o mi ba te vecnu lo matne > > There is an idea of me buying butter to begin with, and then, as a > result, there is an action of me going to the market.

OK.

Now we would need an example where jalge works and krinu doesn't, to show that jalge is more general, or an example where krinu works and jalge doesn't, to show that krinu is more general. (Or both, to show that neither is more general, just different.)

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

무명씨 · 2008-11-10 23:57 UTC · Tiki post #7552 · reply to Tiki post #7378

To the best of my knowledge, "I will buy butter" is not a motive."I have run

out of butter" is a motive.

On Mon, Nov 10, 2008 at 8:28 AM, Jorge Llambías <[email protected]>wrote:

> On Sun, Nov 9, 2008 at 4:34 PM, Adam D. Lopresto <[email protected]> > wrote: > > > > I've always thought that {se ja'e ma} is the most general version. It's > > just > > "as a result of", without specifying what kind of result. > > I think {se jalge} definitely covers {rinka}, but I'm not sure it > covers all kinds of {mukti}. A motive can be an event that is > (potentially) in the future of the event it motivates. Can a result > occur before what it results from? For example: > > lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne cu mukti lo nu mi klama le zarci > I will buy butter motivates I go to the market. > I go to the market to buy butter. > > lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne cu krinu lo nu mi klama le zarci > I will buy butter is the reason I go to the market. > I go to the market because I will buy butter. > > both sound acceptable. I'm not sure about: > >  ? lo nu mi klama le zarci cu jalge lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne >  ? I go to the market is the resut of I will buy butter. > > mu'o mi'e xorxes > > > To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] > with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if > you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help. >

>

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-10 23:59 UTC · Tiki post #7553 · reply to Tiki post #7378

Or, more correctly, "I need butter, and I have run out of butter" is a

motive.

On Mon, Nov 10, 2008 at 3:56 PM, Elias Friedman <[email protected]> wrote:

> To the best of my knowledge, "I will buy butter" is not a motive."I have > run out of butter" is a motive. > > > On Mon, Nov 10, 2008 at 8:28 AM, Jorge Llambías <[email protected]>wrote: > >> On Sun, Nov 9, 2008 at 4:34 PM, Adam D. Lopresto <[email protected]> >> wrote: >> > >> > I've always thought that {se ja'e ma} is the most general version. It's >> > just >> > "as a result of", without specifying what kind of result. >> >> I think {se jalge} definitely covers {rinka}, but I'm not sure it >> covers all kinds of {mukti}. A motive can be an event that is >> (potentially) in the future of the event it motivates. Can a result >> occur before what it results from? For example: >> >> lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne cu mukti lo nu mi klama le zarci >> I will buy butter motivates I go to the market. >> I go to the market to buy butter. >> >> lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne cu krinu lo nu mi klama le zarci >> I will buy butter is the reason I go to the market. >> I go to the market because I will buy butter. >> >> both sound acceptable. I'm not sure about: >> >>  ? lo nu mi klama le zarci cu jalge lo nu mi ba te vecnu lo matne >>  ? I go to the market is the resut of I will buy butter. >> >> mu'o mi'e xorxes >> >> >> To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to >> [email protected] >> with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if >> you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help. >> >>

>

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-11 02:04 UTC · Tiki post #7554 · reply to Tiki post #7378

> mu'e mi'e tijlan

>

  • mu'o


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-11 02:04 UTC · Tiki post #7555 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/11 Elias Friedman <[email protected]>:

> Or, more correctly, "I need butter, and I have run out of butter" is a > motive.

In my opinion, "I need butter, and I have run out of butter" can first motivate the intention "I will buy butter", which can then motivate the agent to realize the action "I go to the market".

mu'e mi'e tijlan


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-11 03:51 UTC · Tiki post #7556 · reply to Tiki post #7378

"I will buy butter" and "I go to the market" can, I believe, be considered

to be parts of one phrase, "I go to the market to buy butter". Such an action could be motivated, to the best of my knowledge, by "I have run out of butter, and I need butter".

"I will buy butter" is not by itself a motive.

On Mon, Nov 10, 2008 at 6:00 PM, tijlan <[email protected]> wrote:

> > mu'e mi'e tijlan > > > > * mu'o > > > To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] > with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if > you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help. >

>

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-11 14:06 UTC · Tiki post #7560 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/11 Elias Friedman <[email protected]>:

> "I will buy butter" and "I go to the market" can, I believe, be considered > to be parts of one phrase, "I go to the market to buy butter".

It can.

But, cognition-wise, the order should be the other way around: "To buy butter, I go to the market". You don't go to the market and then firstly realize that what has motivated the action is the idea "to buy butter", usually.


> Such an action could be motivated, to the best of my knowledge, > by "I have run out of butter, and I need butter".

It could.

But you can be precise a few steps further:

The condition "I have run out of butter and I need butter" motivates the intention "I am willing to buy butter" which motivates the action "I go to the market.

> "I will buy butter" is not by itself a motive.

As an objectively unrealized future action, no it isn't. But as a subjectively perceived current idea, yes it is.

This begs the question: Can such a statement "I will buy butter" be other than a perceptual idea? Can it have factual/historical bearings at all?


mu'o mi'e tijlan


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-12 01:07 UTC · Tiki post #7569 · reply to Tiki post #7378

"To buy butter, I go to the market" and "I go to the market to buy butter"

are fully synonymous. The order of "to buy butter" and "I go to the market" has no effect on the sentence's meaning.

A motive is a reason for someone to do something. "To buy butter" is not a motive, as it is not a reason; it is only the "to do something".

"I am willing to buy butter" is not an intention; it is a personal condition. An intention would be "I intend to buy butter".

An intention cannot motivate an action, as an intention is not a reason for someone to do something; it is an intent to do something.

"I will buy butter" is under no circumstances by itself a motive, as such an

action is not a reason for someone to do something.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-12 03:06 UTC · Tiki post #7570 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/12 Elias Friedman <[email protected]>:

> "To buy butter, I go to the market" and "I go to the market to buy butter" > are fully synonymous.

They are, linguistically.

> The order of "to buy butter" and "I go to the market" > has no effect on the sentence's meaning.

Right. My point was that their order is significant cognition-wise. A personal motive for the action "I go to the market" in this case is a cognitive phenomenon. The idea "to buy butter" can cognitively motivate the action "go to the market", just like other ideas such as "I need butter, and I have run out of butter" can.

An established intentional idea can be internally influential enough to the point where it motivates you to do something without having you to question the original reason for that action. Imagine: You notice you have run out of butter. But you need butter. So you intend "to buy butter"; you establish this idea. Later, you remember your intention "I will buy butter", and *that* motivates you to go to the market. Here you are self-reflectively observing a state in which you once intended to buy butter. This state is now as objective an item as the state "I need butter, and I have run out of butter". If the latter state can be a motive, so can the former too. They are equaly contents of consciousness by which the agent can be motivated to go to the market.


> "I am willing to buy butter" is not an intention; it is a personal > condition. An intention would be "I intend to buy butter".

An intention is a personal condition. You intend something because you are cognitively/psychologically/neurologically conditioned in a particular way. You intend to buy butter because your personal (cognitive) condition is such that you realize you have run out of butter and you need it. Should the condition differ, your intention would differ.

I don't see much point in drawing a line between "I am willing to buy butter" and "I intend to buy butter" for this matter. They are both statements about an intentional state of "I", and they can both be contents of consciousness by which, in a self-reflective manner, "I" can be motivated to do something.


mu'o mi'e tijlan


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-12 04:42 UTC · Tiki post #7572 · reply to Tiki post #7378

The action "to buy butter" cannot be a motive. A motive is something that

causes a person to do a certain thing. The action "to buy butter", by itself, cannot motivate; "to buy butter" is the "certain thing" for the person to do. The order of these phrases has no meaningful significance, and would not, even if one phrase motivated the other.

"I will buy butter" is not an intention; it is a future action.

If someone were to remember his or her intent to buy butter, that would not be motivation to buy butter; it would simply be a recollection of his or her intent. The motive would remain as "I have run out of butter, and I need butter". "I intend to buy butter" cannot be a motive because such an intent is not a reason for the person to buy butter.

An intention is not a personal condition; it is a course of action that a person intends to follow.

"I am willing to buy butter" and "I intend to buy butter" have a meaningful difference. "I am willing to buy butter" expresses willingness; "I intend to buy butter" expresses intent. "I am willing to buy butter" does not express an intentional state of "I", it expresses the willingness of "I".

Neither phrase can motivate.

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-12 14:25 UTC · Tiki post #7576 · reply to Tiki post #7378

If we are talking about the English word "motive", then it seems that

"to do something" can be a motive. For example, a Google search for "his motive was to" gives thousands of hits, such as:

his motive was to cover up a politically embarassing problem for his bosses; his motive "was to rid the world of a few needless illegals." his motive was to save his own life, M. Kerviel said his motive was to "make money for the bank" In fact, his motive was to attract votes from the border states; His motive was to learn the campaign strategies of

And so on. So generally goals of actions can be the motives of those actions in English, though maybe the word "motive" is reserved for more significant goals than a trivial one like "to buy butter".

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-12 15:35 UTC · Tiki post #7578 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/12 Elias Friedman <[email protected]>:

> The action "to buy butter" cannot be a motive.

I didn't say it was an action; I said it was an intention, an idea. We can be motivated by ideas.


> A motive is something that causes a person to do a certain thing.

.ie


> "I will buy butter" is not an intention; it is a future action.

Is a perceived future action really an action or an idea? When we say "I will buy butter", are we reporting an action or an idea?


> If someone were to remember his or her intent to buy butter, that would not > be motivation to buy butter; it would simply be a recollection of his or her > intent.

And what would happen to them after recollecting their intent? Wouldn't they *do something* (including "staying in their house")? Is it impossible to suppose at least that the recollection can motivate them to re-observe the state "I need butter, and I have run out of them", which means an intention as an idea *can* motivate?


> The motive would remain as "I have run out of butter, and I need > butter". "I intend to buy butter" cannot be a motive because such an intent > is not a reason for the person to buy butter.

"I have run out of butter, and I need butter" as a reason can be sufficiently referred with "krinu". If you are asked "Why do you go to the market", you can justify your action with "krinu". It need not be restricted to "mukti" alone.

"mukti", on the other hand, is more about incentives which need not be logically (nibli) or rationally (krinu) grounded. As a motive to go to the market, you can point to a feeling or emotion:

"Why do you go to the market?" "Because I feel like it." ("My feeling motivates.")

Likewise:

"What does motivate you to go to the market?" "The idea of going to there." or "My will."

("My will" itself can be motivated by yet another factor, which can be, in this case, the perception of "I have run out of butter, and I need butter".)


> An intention is not a personal condition; it is a course of action that a > person intends to follow.

If koha has a particular course of action that koha intends to follow, it conditions that koha's future action is likely to be of a particular one. Koha's intention conditions koha's action. Therefore an individual intention is an individual condition.


mu'o mi'e tijlan


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-13 02:09 UTC · Tiki post #7581 · reply to Tiki post #7378

Jorge, the situations you have mentioned in your message are not using

"motive" correctly; in place of "motive", those statements should be using "action". A motive is a reason for someone to do something; in the situations you have mentioned, the "to do something

is incorrectly being called a motive.

For example, in the situation "to cover up a politically embarrassing problem for his bosses", the person's motive is, most likely, the necessity of keeping his job.

Also, in the situation "to attract votes from the border states", the person's motive is, most likely, his or her desire to win the election.

A goal of an action cannot be a motive of the same action; however, the necessity of such a goal's realization can be a motive of the action.

I have also performed a Google search for "his motive was to", and I came across many results following my definition of "motive"; I saw very few usages in the manner you described.


tijlan, It does not matter whether or not you said that "to buy butter" was an action, as it is an action regardlessly. "To buy butter" is not an intention. Whether or not one can be motivated by ideas is not relevant, as "to buy butter" is not a motivational idea. Whether or not "I will buy butter" is an action or an idea is not relevant; "I will buy butter" is still not an intention.

If someone recalled his or her intent to buy butter, the intent is not a motive for the person to recall the state "I have run out of butter, and I need butter"; rather, the person would be motivated to recall such a state by his or her desire or need to recall.

"I need butter" is a mukti, as "I need butter" is a motive for an event, the purchase of butter; "I have run out of butter" is a krinu, as "I have run out of butter" is the reason for the person's need of butter.

A person's will by itself cannot serve as a motive, as a motive is a reason for someone to do something.

Although a person's intention can condition his or her action, his or her

intention is not a condition.

le gusta co minde mutce

Anonymous · 2008-11-13 12:18 UTC · Tiki post #7582 · reply to Tiki post #7378

On Wed, Nov 12, 2008 at 11:07 PM, Elias Friedman <[email protected]> wrote:

> Jorge, the situations you have mentioned in your message are not using > "motive" correctly; in place of "motive", those statements should be using > "action".

If you replace "motive" with "action" in those sentences, the meaning changes: Compare:

(1) his motive was to attract votes from the border states (2) his action was to attract votes from the border states

(1) doesn't say that he attracted votes from border states: he did something else with the goal of attracting votes from the border states (which goal may or may not have been attained). (2) says that he did attract votes from the border states.

> A motive is a reason for someone to do something;

Yes, certainly. A motive is whatever moves someone to do something.

> in the > situations you have mentioned, the "to do something > is incorrectly being called a motive.

It's the goal that moved them to do whatever it is they did. Here's a dictionary definition of "motive":

1. something that causes a person to act in a certain way, do a certain thing, etc.; incentive. 2. the goal or object of a person's actions: Her motive was revenge.

The examples I gave are all of sense 2.

> For example, in the situation "to cover up a politically embarrassing > problem for his bosses", the person's motive is, most likely, the necessity > of keeping his job.

Yes, that's probably part of the chain of motives: in order to keep their job, they needed to cover up the embarrassing problem, and in order to cover up the problem, they did whatever it is they did. But it doesn't matter what the "real" motive behind their action is, the point is what kind of thing can properly be claimed as a motive. "To cover up a politically embarrassing problem" is something that can be claimed as a motive. Whether or not deep down that was the real or most important motive is a separate issue.

> Also, in the situation "to attract votes from the border states", the > person's motive is, most likely, his or her desire to win the election. > A goal of an action cannot be a motive of the same action; however, the > necessity of such a goal's realization can be a motive of the action.

Here's the context for that quote:

"An Op-Ed article Wednesday on doing away with the office of vice president indicated that President Lincoln's motive for choosing his second-term running mate, Andrew Johnson, was to carry Tennessee. In fact, his motive was to attract votes from the border states;"

Lincoln's action was choosing Johnson as his running mate. His motive for that action, according to the Op-Ed article, was to carry Tennessee. His real motive, according to this other article, was to attract votes from the border states.

> I have also performed a Google search for "his motive was to", and I came > across many results following my definition of "motive"; I saw very few > usages in the manner you described.

The ones I gave were all from the first page of hits, I didn't have to look hard for them. And I have no problem with your definition. But for some reason you want to exclude the goals of an action as something that can move someone to carry out that action.

> tijlan, > It does not matter whether or not you said that "to buy butter" was an > action, as it is an action regardlessly. "To buy butter" is not an > intention.

But "my intention is to buy butter" seems like a normal thing to say. What is an intention if not something that someone intends to do?

mu'o mi'e xorxes


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.

le gusta co minde mutce

tijlan · 2008-11-13 13:30 UTC · Tiki post #7583 · reply to Tiki post #7378

2008/11/13 Elias Friedman <[email protected]>:

> It does not matter whether or not you said that "to buy butter" was an > action, as it is an action regardlessly.

The fact that the linguistic unit contains a verb does not necessarily mean its utterer has a factual action in mind. It basically means the utterer is signifying an *idea* of an action/verb.


> "To buy butter" is not an > intention. Whether or not one can be motivated by ideas is not relevant, as > "to buy butter" is not a motivational idea. > Whether or not "I will buy butter" is an action or an idea is not relevant; > "I will buy butter" is still not an intention. > If someone recalled his or her intent to buy butter, the intent is not a > motive for the person to recall the state "I have run out of butter, and I > need butter"; rather, the person would be motivated to recall such a state > by his or her desire or need to recall. > "I need butter" is a mukti, as "I need butter" is a motive for an event, the > purchase of butter; "I have run out of butter" is a krinu, as "I have run > out of butter" is the reason for the person's need of butter. > A person's will by itself cannot serve as a motive, as a motive is a reason > for someone to do something. > Although a person's intention can condition his or her action, his or her > intention is not a condition.

I'm not going to insist on my point any more. I'm prepared to interpret "to buy butter" in either way. I'll let usage decide. English is not even my first language. I have no reason to specify how Lojban should interact with English.


mi'e tijlan


To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to [email protected] with the subject unsubscribe, or go to http://www.lojban.org/lsg2/, or if

you're really stuck, send mail to [email protected] for help.