Talk:Tiki forum archive/Forum 1/3618

From Lojban

Source: 2013 Tiki forum 1, thread #3618. Original authors, UTC times, post IDs, and reply-parent IDs are preserved. This is an archive, not an active article discussion.

[[email protected]: Relative Clauses and Phrases]

[[email protected]: Relative Clauses and Phrases]

xorxes · 2005-01-12 01:43 UTC · Tiki post #3618

> I can't go from your comment here to an answer to the questions in

> your first mail. > > -Robin

Ok, I'll fill in the answers.

> > I assume {ko'a goi le prenu} is equivalent to {le prenu ku goi > ko'a}. > > Are {le prenu goi ko'a ku} and {le goi ko'a prenu ku} also > equivalent > > to the first two?

Yes.

> > I assume that in {ci le mu prenu goi ko'a ku} and in > > {ci le goi ko'a mu prenu ku}, {ko'a} gets assigned {le mu prenu > ku}.

The first one yes. The second one, I think it was defined that {le goi ...} behaves as {le ... ku goi}, so the assignment would be as below.

> > What happens with {ko'a goi ci le mu prenu} and {ci le mu prenu ku > > goi ko'a}? Presumably ko'a gets assigned the three people which > > fulfill whatever will be claimed about them?

Yes.

> > What if the assignment occurs under the scope of another > quantifier? > > > > ro le ze gerku cu batci ci le mu prenu ku goi ko'a > > "Each of the seven dogs bites three of the five people, from now > on > > ko'a" > > > > If we use ko'a in the next sentence, does this force an > interpretation > > on the first sentence that every dog bit the same three people? Or > does > > ko'a refer to all of the five people that were bitten, even if > there's > > more than three in all?

{ko'a} in this case should in principle not be usable outside of the scope of {ro le ze gerku}.

> > Is {ko'a goi no le mu prenu} at all meaningful?

No.

> > Does {su'eci le mu prenu ku goi ko'a} force existential import > > into {su'eci} ("at most three")?

{su'eci le mu prenu ku goi ko'a cu broda} presupposes {su'opa le mu prenu cu broda} (which has nothing to do with "existential import").

mu'o mi'e xorxes



__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Meet the all-new My Yahoo! - Try it today! http://my.yahoo.com