LLG 2018 Annual Meeting Minutes

From Lojban

(Unapproved Draft)

These are the minutes of the 2018 Annual Meeting of the members of the Logical Language Group, as conducted in a Mattermost channel from October 4, 2018 to July 11, 2019. This was the first Members Meeting held on the Mattermost forum. A complete transcript is available.

Announcement

The 2018 Members Meeting was announced on September 26, 2018 by the president.

Call to order

The meeting began on October 4, 2018 with a call to order by president Karen Stein (.karis.).

John Cowan served as parliamentarian.

Roll call

Participants were asked to state that they were present and to give the name they use in the Lojban community. Members answering the initial roll call included:

  • Pierre Abbat (phma/.piier.)
  • Arkadii Balandin (gleki)
  • Sylvain Déjardin (.ilmen.)
  • Curtis Franks (.krtisfranks.)
  • Ali Sajid Imami (.banseljaj.)
  • Nora LeChevalier (.noras.)
  • Robert LeChevalier (.lojbab.)
  • Jorge Llambías (.xorxes.)
  • And Rosta
  • Karen Stein (.karis.)
  • Veijo Vilva (.veion.)

Members who joined after the initial roll call included:

  • Robin Lee Powell (.camgusmis.)
  • Riley Martinez-Lynch (mukti)

Non-member participants included apieum, Aris Merchant (BookOfPortals/.eris.), Andrew Browne (dersaidin), John Cowan, greg_g, junpen, la .robotin.daiter., solpahi, uakci, Wesley Wilson (.ueslis.), xanri and zazypap.

And Rosta, who had previously resigned, was allowed to continue as a member because the membership list on lojban.org had not been updated to reflect his resignation.

Proof of notice

The president asked whether anyone objected that notice of the meeting was insufficient. As no objection was raised, notice was deemed sufficient.

Reading of minutes

By general consent, the reading of the minutes of the previous meeting was postponed until the secretary was able to present them. They were not read during this meeting.

Officers' reports

President's report

President's Report for 2018:

The main accomplishments of LLG, from my perspective, for the past year are as follows. The financial report will be provided separately.

Most obvious is the move of meetings out of an email listserv format to Mattermost. This occurred first with the Board Meeting, with the transition completed in July. Briefly, the Board wanted meetings to be easier to follow, without messages being lost or mixed in with messages about other subjects, saved in full, and in a format more conducive to creating minutes. Feedback during our after this meeting about the new format would be greatly appreciated.

Further, I am happy to announce that the LLG officers, myself, lojbab, and mukti, were able to have a face to face meeting in Virginia at the home of lojbab and noras in August. We all found it helpful as well as enjoyable.

Finally, I am quite pleased to see so many people have joined the meeting in our new setting. At this time there are 31 people in attendance. I hope this is indicative that we will have lively discussion and active participation by many of you as the meeting proceeds.

Secretary/Treasurerʻs Report

The president relayed a report from Riley Martinez-Lynch (mukti), secretary/treasurer. He was keeping up with the quarterly tax filings and finalizing the annual corporate filing, and could be reached as needed, though his time was limited by a new job. No financial figures were posted to the meeting.

Committee reports

BPFK

Miles Forster (selpa'i), jatna of BPFK, reported through the president that there had been no BPFK activity since the last report.

Election of new members

Wesley Wilson (.ueslis.) was proposed for membership on November 18, 2018 and was admitted 11–0 on January 9, 2019.

Aris Merchant (bookofportals/.eris.) was admitted on March 13, 2019 by unanimous consent.

Removal of old members

Alex Burka resigned his membership by a message to the llg-members list dated January 3, 2019.

Old business

BPFK

selpa'i, jatna of BPFK, said he was willing to continue if no one else wanted the role. .karis. moved, seconded by phma, that LLG re-elect selpa'i for another year as jatna of BPFK. The motion was postponed on March 4, 2019 until the future of BPFK was decided.

gleki moved, seconded by Curtis Franks, that "BPFK is directed to present all internal materials with its official decisions to the LLG Membership including, but not limited to xorlo. It should be an exhaustive list." The motion passed on February 14, 2019 with 5 for, 0 against and 2 abstaining. The president directed the current and former BPFK jatna to compile this material for the Board before July 31, 2019.

selpa'i shared the BPFK Decisions page. It was noted that xorlo had been recognized by LLG in the 2007 meeeting. A separate "BPFK/byfy Decisions" channel was opened to collect further records.

New business

Lojban community

gleki reported that lalxu had improved the front page of the wiki, and that he had rewritten the chat bridge, which now reaches Facebook and VK. Russian-language activity on the #rusko channel was described as active, with about ten fluent speakers.

lojbab and karis proposed an informal periodic survey of Lojban learners, asking about location, skill and activity, to give LLG a clearer picture of the community.

lojbo fuzykamni (LFK)

bookofportals proposed replacing BPFK with a new committee, the lojbo fuzykamni (LFK), open to the whole community through a Request for Comment process and making decisions by consensus. Discussion centred on whether LFK decisions could become official without a vote of the members, whether a new committee was needed at all, and how to avoid fragmenting the language. A first version, moved on April 14, 2019, was withdrawn.

The revised proposal, seconded by ilmen, dissolved BPFK and commissioned LFK as a standing committee. Standards adopted by LFK are "candidate standards" until ratified by LLG by majority vote. The motion passed on May 22, 2019 with 3 for, 1 against and 1 abstaining. The president set BPFK's dissolution to take effect at the start of the next Members Meeting, so that its members could provide English documentation of all past decisions.

On May 27, 2019 the president moved to create an "LFK Initial Documents Committee" to prepare announcements and a job description for LFK, seconded by bookofportals. lojbab raised a point of order that the chair may not make motions. The president withdrew the motion and instead opened a public channel for this work on June 23, 2019.

Authorized update of CLL

gleki moved that on updating CLL and publishing official materials, LLG listen to the opinion of lojbab and John Cowan (la balgenpre). The motion died for lack of a second.

gleki moved, seconded by ilmen, a one-time process for correcting typographical errors in CLL. gleki would circulate the list of proposed corrections to LLG voting members, John W. Cowan and fluent speakers, collect their vetoes, then compile a new version of CLL for LLG approval. The motion was amended without objection to name John Cowan, who holds a reserved veto over changes to CLL. It passed on June 26, 2019 with 4 for, 0 against and 2 abstaining. The president asked that the public announcement be reviewed in the Board channel before publication.

Election of the Board

And Rosta asked to stand, seconded by gleki. The following slate was elected on July 7, 2019, each receiving 5 votes for, none against and no abstentions:

  • Balandin, Arkadii
  • Franks, Curtis
  • Imami, Ali Sajid
  • LeChevalier, Robert
  • Martinez-Lynch, Riley
  • Rosta, And
  • Stein, Karen

Adjournment

bookofportals moved to adjourn, seconded by phma. The motion carried on July 11, 2019 with 5 for, none against and no abstentions. The next Members Meeting was set to begin on or about September 7, 2019. Items raised for that meeting were the election of LFK members (bookofportals) and a further cycle of CLL corrections (gleki).