opposites and contraries: Difference between revisions

From Lojban
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
==Opposites & Contraries==
The distinction between opposites ('''da de dukti'''), traceable to William Blake (if not earlier), can be discerned in Lojban in a shadowy way. Simply put, opposites undo each other ("hot"-to-"cold") while contraries form two parts of a whole ("left" or "right"). The metaphors of [[binary thinking]] tend not to take cognizance of this distinction, which is essential to clear reasoning. But which of these two classes the pair fits into depends on perspective; someone could just as rightly claim that "left" and "right" cancel each other out, as directions, and "hot" and "cold" are the two ends of the heat spectrum, making them parts of a whole. Thus the distinction is arbitrary, not absolute. It's akin to the physical phenomenon of energy sometimes being thought of as a particle and other times as a wave; neither type is actually distinguishable in nature, they are only different ways to envision the same concept.


Opposites & Contraries.
Contraries ('''da de te vlina''') are about propositions.
==List==


The distinction between opposites (''da de dukti'') & contraries (''da de vlina''), traceable to William Blake (if not earlier), can be discerned in Lojban in a shadowy way. Simply put, opposites undo each other ("hot"-to-"cold") while contraries form two parts of a whole ("left" or "right"). The metaphors of [[binary thinking|binary thinking]] tend not to take cognizance of this distinction, which is essential to clear reasoning. ''But which of these two classes the pair fits into depends on perspective; someone could just as rightly claim that "left" and "right" cancel each other out, as direcions, and "hot" and "cold" are the two ends of the heat spectrum, making them parts of a whole. Thus the distinction is arbitrary, not absolute.  It's akin to the physical phenomenon of energy sometimes being thought of as a particle and other times as a wave; neither type is actually distinguishable in nature, they are only different ways to envision the same concept.''
<tab class=wikitable>
cmalu barda
nanmu ninmu
nanla nixli
xlali xamgu
ruble tsali
mutce milxe
jetnu jitfa
pritu zunle
fatci cfika
birka tuple
xance jamfu
preti danfu
nandu frili
balvi purci
nenri bartu
jmive morsi
masno sutra
gusni manku
tordu clani
sampu pluja
xekri blabi
zmadu mleca
cnita gapru
sipna cikna
donri nicte
cerni vanci
jmina vimcu
ricfu pindi
cnino slabu
jibni darno
bebna prije
vensa critu
dunra crisa
clira lerci
carmi kandi
berti snanu
stuna stici
crane trixe
bersa tixnu
mensi bruna
tilju linto
glare lenku
sudga cilmo
kanro bilma
tcadu nurma
slami jilka
danlu spati
smaji cladu
caxno condi
ganlo kalri
dizlo galtu
loldi drudi
ganra jarki
rotsu cinla
palci vrude
tisna kunti
frica dunli
drata mintu
zabna mabla
fliba snada
gubni sivni
rarna rutni
junri xalbo
gunta bandu
xendo kusru
racli fenki
</tab>


How does ''vlina'' enter into any of this? Was ''da de te vlina'' meant? Isn't ''vlina'' about propositions? --[[User:xorxes|xorxes]]


----
==Dubious cases==
 
<tab class=wikitable>
''Which are these meant to be -- opposites or contraries? Most fit neither description above: neither cancelling out (to lukewarm?) nor being parts of some discernable whole.''
cirko facki
 
cirko cpacu
-----------
jdari ranti
 
sepli kansa
cmalu barda
sepli jorne
 
krasi fanmo
nanmu ninmu
drani srera
 
cnici kalsa
nanla nixli
kukte kurki
 
</tab>
xlali xamgu
 
ruble tsali
 
mutce milxe
 
jetnu jitfa
 
pritu zunle
 
fatci cfika
 
birka tuple
 
xance jamfu
 
preti danfu
 
nandu frili
 
balvi purci
 
nenri bartu
 
jmive morsi
 
masno sutra
 
gusni manku
 
tordu clani
 
sampu pluja
 
xekri blabi
 
zmadu mleca
 
cnita gapru
 
sipna cikna
 
donri nicte
 
cerni vanci
 
jmina vimcu
 
ricfu pindi
 
cnino slabu
 
jibni darno
 
bebna prije
 
vensa critu
 
dunra crisa
 
clira lerci
 
carmi kandi
 
berti snanu
 
stuna stici
 
crane trixe
 
bersa tixnu
 
mensi bruna
 
tilju linto
 
glare lenku
 
sudga cilmo
 
kanro bilma
 
tcadu nurma
 
slami jilka
 
danlu spati
 
smaji cladu
 
caxno condi
 
ganlo kalri
 
dizlo galtu
 
loldi drudi
 
ganra jarki
 
rotsu cinla
 
palci vrude
 
tisna kunti
 
frica dunli
 
drata mintu
 
zabna mabla
 
fliba snada
 
gubni sivni
 
rarna rutni
 
junri xalbo
 
gunta bandu
 
xendo kusru
 
racli fenki
 
----
 
'''Dubious cases'''
 
cirko facki (cpacu)
 
jdari ranti
 
sepli kansa (jorne)
 
krasi fanmo
 
drani srera
 
cnici kalsa
 
kukte kurki

Revision as of 14:53, 27 February 2015

Opposites & Contraries

The distinction between opposites (da de dukti), traceable to William Blake (if not earlier), can be discerned in Lojban in a shadowy way. Simply put, opposites undo each other ("hot"-to-"cold") while contraries form two parts of a whole ("left" or "right"). The metaphors of binary thinking tend not to take cognizance of this distinction, which is essential to clear reasoning. But which of these two classes the pair fits into depends on perspective; someone could just as rightly claim that "left" and "right" cancel each other out, as directions, and "hot" and "cold" are the two ends of the heat spectrum, making them parts of a whole. Thus the distinction is arbitrary, not absolute. It's akin to the physical phenomenon of energy sometimes being thought of as a particle and other times as a wave; neither type is actually distinguishable in nature, they are only different ways to envision the same concept.

Contraries (da de te vlina) are about propositions.

List

<tab class=wikitable> cmalu barda nanmu ninmu nanla nixli xlali xamgu ruble tsali mutce milxe jetnu jitfa pritu zunle fatci cfika birka tuple xance jamfu preti danfu nandu frili balvi purci nenri bartu jmive morsi masno sutra gusni manku tordu clani sampu pluja xekri blabi zmadu mleca cnita gapru sipna cikna donri nicte cerni vanci jmina vimcu ricfu pindi cnino slabu jibni darno bebna prije vensa critu dunra crisa clira lerci carmi kandi berti snanu stuna stici crane trixe bersa tixnu mensi bruna tilju linto glare lenku sudga cilmo kanro bilma tcadu nurma slami jilka danlu spati smaji cladu caxno condi ganlo kalri dizlo galtu loldi drudi ganra jarki rotsu cinla palci vrude tisna kunti frica dunli drata mintu zabna mabla fliba snada gubni sivni rarna rutni junri xalbo gunta bandu xendo kusru racli fenki </tab>


Dubious cases

<tab class=wikitable> cirko facki cirko cpacu jdari ranti sepli kansa sepli jorne krasi fanmo drani srera cnici kalsa kukte kurki </tab>