naku: Difference between revisions

From Lojban
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
 
mNo edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:


== Haikus by Cmacis ==
See also [[jbocre: le broda ku na brode Gotcha|le broda ku na brode Gotcha]].


<pre>
''naku'' is a bridi negation like ''na'', meaning "It is false that..."


doi pendo be mi
but it interacts differently with quantifiers.  In this use, ''[[jbocre: ku|ku]]'' cannot be elided, since that would make ''na'' and ''naku'' indistinguishable.


.uinai do mi na prami
In particular, when creating a prenex for a sentence, ''na'' is immediately put at the beginning of the prenex (and turns into ''naku'', since ''na'' can't syntactically appear in a prenex); ''naku'' goes into the prenex in bridi order, intermixed with any quantifiers -- to move it to the front, [[jbocre: DeMorgan's Laws|DeMorgan's Laws]] must be applied.


.i mi ca klaku
Thus "All men don't have hair" can be represented in Lojban as


doi cmalu crisa
* ro nanmu na se kerfa


ma zvati le do gugde
which prenexes as


.u'i zo'o nai
* naku ro da poi nanmu zo'u kerfa daIt is false that for each X that is a man, (something) is X's hair


coi melbi ninmu
which is true: some men are bald. On the other hand,


mi ca nitcu tu'a do
* ro nanmu naku se kerfa


.i do xu kakne
prenexes as


mi mutce nelci
* ro da poi nanmu naku zo'u kerfa daFor each X that is a man, it is false that (something) is X's hair


lo ka sutra vacri poi
which is false: not ''all'' men are bald.
 
mutce nelci mi
 
</pre>
 
These can be heard on [http://jbobac.lojban.org/ jbobac]

Revision as of 17:06, 4 November 2013

See also le broda ku na brode Gotcha.

naku is a bridi negation like na, meaning "It is false that..."

but it interacts differently with quantifiers. In this use, ku cannot be elided, since that would make na and naku indistinguishable.

In particular, when creating a prenex for a sentence, na is immediately put at the beginning of the prenex (and turns into naku, since na can't syntactically appear in a prenex); naku goes into the prenex in bridi order, intermixed with any quantifiers -- to move it to the front, DeMorgan's Laws must be applied.

Thus "All men don't have hair" can be represented in Lojban as

  • ro nanmu na se kerfa

which prenexes as

  • naku ro da poi nanmu zo'u kerfa daIt is false that for each X that is a man, (something) is X's hair

which is true: some men are bald. On the other hand,

  • ro nanmu naku se kerfa

prenexes as

  • ro da poi nanmu naku zo'u kerfa daFor each X that is a man, it is false that (something) is X's hair

which is false: not all men are bald.