Arabic Orthography: Difference between revisions

From Lojban
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (Gleki moved page arabic Orthography to Arabic Orthography over a redirect without leaving a redirect)
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
 
*.filip.:
 
**I thought of using Arabic letters to write Lojban.
I (mi'e filip.) thought of using Arabic letters to write Lojban.
**The consonants are pretty straightforward, especially if you use Persian rather than Arabic as a base (which adds '''g''', '''j''', '''p''', and '''tc''', of which we need the first three).
 
**I thought of using the existing vowel signs for the Lojban vowels. Since Arabic has only three signs compared to Lojban's six vowels, I thought of using the "doubled" signs (-n endings) for the "real" vowels and "single" signs for "close" vowels - that is, vowels which aren't the same as the standard Arabic vowel but which are sometimes represented with the same vowel sign anyway.
The consonants are pretty straightforward, especially if you use Persian rather than Arabic as a base (which adds '''g''', '''j''', '''p''', and '''tc''', of which we need the first three).
**This gives kasra/kasratan for '''e/i''', damma/dammatan for '''o/u''', and fathatan for '''a'''. This leaves '''y''' to go with fatha.
 
**I propose using alif for '''.''' since it's a glottal stop, and heh for '''<nowiki>'</nowiki>''' because of the pronunciation. I couldn't think of anything particularly good for ''',''' so I picked ''yeh with hamza''. I also need a "null" consonant for diphthongs to carry the second vowel sign; I picked `ayn.
I thought of using the existing vowel signs for the Lojban vowels. Since Arabic has only three signs compared to Lojban's six vowels, I thought of using the "doubled" signs (-n endings) for the "real" vowels and "single" signs for "close" vowels -- that is, vowels which aren't the same as the standard Arabic vowel but which are sometimes represented with the same vowel sign anyway.
**So here's my proposal. What do you think?
 
**[[Image:lojban-xrabo.png]]
This gives kasra/kasratan for e/i, damma/dammatan for o/u, and fathatan for a. This leaves y to go with fatha.
***.aulun.:
 
****Doesn't look bad - and it seems you are using front, middle, end and single type variants of Arabic (Farsi) characters. Yet, it also seems you didn't do this by normal typing but by composing the samples by means of a graphic tool ;-) I therefore think that - different from Yiddish mode - it is a hard job to 'really use' Arabic for Lojban writing. Nevertheless, nice idea.
I propose using alif for '''.''' since it's a glottal stop, and heh for ''''''' because of the pronunciation. I couldn't think of anything particularly good for ''',''' so I picked ''yeh with hamza''. I also need a "null" consonant for diphthongs to carry the second vowel sign; I picked `ayn.
*****.filip.:
 
******I did indeed use a tool [http://www.unipad.org/ SC UniPad] which automatically shapes Arabic letters (and does RTL automatically for Hebrew, Arabic, and Syriac, too). The screenshot is from UniPad.
So here's my proposal. What do you think?
*******.aulun.:
 
********Great! Without need of extra fonts. Yet, Macintosh again excluded :[
[http://shavian.org/lojban/lojban-xrabo.png]
 
''Doesn't look bad - and it seems you are using front, middle, end and single type variants of Arabic (Farsi) characters. Yet, it also seems you didn't do this by normal typing but by composing the samples by means of a graphic tool ;-) I therefore think that - different from Yiddish mode - it is a hard job to 'really use' Arabic for Lojban writing. Nevertheless, nice idea. -- .aulun.''
 
*I did indeed use a tool -- [http://www.unipad.org/ C UniPad] which automatically shapes Arabic letters (and does RTL automatically for Hebrew, Arabic, and Syriac, too). The screenshot is from UniPad.
*''Great! Without need of extra fonts. Yet, Macintosh again excluded :[--.aulun.''


===tcidu ji'a===
===tcidu ji'a===
*[http://jbotcan.org/ideas/#629]
*http://jbotcan.org/ideas/#629
*[http://jbotcan.org/ideas/#630]
*http://jbotcan.org/ideas/#630
*[[xrabo lerfu lo me la .iesk. moi]]
*[[xrabo lerfu lo me la .iesk. moi]]

Revision as of 07:37, 26 April 2015

  • .filip.:
    • I thought of using Arabic letters to write Lojban.
    • The consonants are pretty straightforward, especially if you use Persian rather than Arabic as a base (which adds g, j, p, and tc, of which we need the first three).
    • I thought of using the existing vowel signs for the Lojban vowels. Since Arabic has only three signs compared to Lojban's six vowels, I thought of using the "doubled" signs (-n endings) for the "real" vowels and "single" signs for "close" vowels - that is, vowels which aren't the same as the standard Arabic vowel but which are sometimes represented with the same vowel sign anyway.
    • This gives kasra/kasratan for e/i, damma/dammatan for o/u, and fathatan for a. This leaves y to go with fatha.
    • I propose using alif for . since it's a glottal stop, and heh for ' because of the pronunciation. I couldn't think of anything particularly good for , so I picked yeh with hamza. I also need a "null" consonant for diphthongs to carry the second vowel sign; I picked `ayn.
    • So here's my proposal. What do you think?
    • lojban-xrabo.png
      • .aulun.:
        • Doesn't look bad - and it seems you are using front, middle, end and single type variants of Arabic (Farsi) characters. Yet, it also seems you didn't do this by normal typing but by composing the samples by means of a graphic tool ;-) I therefore think that - different from Yiddish mode - it is a hard job to 'really use' Arabic for Lojban writing. Nevertheless, nice idea.
          • .filip.:
            • I did indeed use a tool SC UniPad which automatically shapes Arabic letters (and does RTL automatically for Hebrew, Arabic, and Syriac, too). The screenshot is from UniPad.
              • .aulun.:
                • Great! Without need of extra fonts. Yet, Macintosh again excluded :[

tcidu ji'a